2 ms·
The concept of "The Best" is meaningless anyway. When someone says "We Hire The Best", ask them to quantify precisely what "The Best" means. They can't. They
by andrewstuart 11y ago
The concept of "The Best" is meaningless anyway.
When someone says "We Hire The Best", ask them to quantify precisely what "The Best" means. They can't. They weasel around and avoid answering. And that is because they can't define in a tangible way what "The Best" is. And if you can't define it then how do you know you found it?
Assuming you can define "The Best", an even bigger problem is working out a provable mechanism for measuring - in a quantifiable way - whether someone meets the criteria for being "The Best".
And the final absolute ripper problem is that the more you strive for "The Best", the less likely tou are to find anyone so you'll spend months interviewing and hiring no-one until the boss decides to pull the budget for that position because you didn't hire someone and anyway the commercial opportunity that validated the hire is now evaporated because we couldn't get the code written.
My term for this is "Voodoo Recruiting" in which there are rituals and dances and songs and meetings and processes and tests but it's all just a magic show because in the end the decision is not scientific, it's a magical outcome based just on personal likes and biases. In Voodoo Recruiting a company forms a set of beliefs about its recruiting processes and practices that become sacred and magical - such as "everyone has to do our test, and it actually tells us something meaningful about the candidates and we know how to interpret the results in a meaningful way".
Here's a few posts I wrote on the topic:
I sent one of the best developers I know to a job interview, he was rejected.
http://fourlightyears.blogspot.com.au/2014/12/i-sent-one-of-best-developers-i-have.html http://fourlightyears.blogspot.com.au/2014/12/i-sent-one-of-...
Employers don't want great developers, they want what they want.
http://fourlightyears.blogspot.com.au/2014/12/employers-dont-want-great-great.html http://fourlightyears.blogspot.com.au/2014/12/employers-dont...
Is your developer recruiting process just stroking your company ego?
http://fourlightyears.blogspot.com.au/2014/12/is-your-poor-developer-recruiting.html http://fourlightyears.blogspot.com.au/2014/12/is-your-poor-d...
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoAt the risk of being rude, some of it is just foam finger, jingoistic narcissism. Much is swept under the rug of "fit". And employers want what they think they want. I've been forced to (inadvertently) undermine the Great Developer too many places to think otherwise. Lest ye think otherwise, I'm not that good. I'm just rigorous but I can switch modes and hack like a shameless... hacker.