5 ms·
So its basically extended interview for like 8 weeks where your every move is being watched/judged. When did it become ok to treat people like shit and humilia
by dominotw 11y ago
So its basically extended interview for like 8 weeks where your every move is being watched/judged.
When did it become ok to treat people like shit and humiliate them with these ridiculous "interviews". Seems like we keep coming up one worse idea after another.
Shame on everyone who thinks its ok to humiliate people with your idiotic algorithm/whiteboard/big O interviews.
This is getting so out of hand. Can we bring some humility and kindness to tech interviews.
- cableshaft 11y agoThat's pretty much every job though. You're generally watched and judged more closely when you first start out anywhere, and it relaxes after you've proven yourself. Even if it's not happening overtly, you can bet it's happening. And not just from your boss, but from coworkers as well.
- dasboth 11y agoThat's true, and some companies are quite liberal with their ability to sack people at a week's notice during their probation period.
- atonse 11y agoThis is one of those examples where a totally well intentioned move is completely misunderstood. What is the purpose of an interview? To see if someone's a good fit and works well with you. Interviews don't tell you that. Working with the people fixes that. At least these are paid contracts. It's one thing if they were unpaid, then sure, yes it sucks. But it's the equivalent of doing a freelance gig for a couple of weeks to see not only if they like you, but if YOU like working at that company. You can evaluate working at a company, get paid to do it, and find out all the pitfalls BEFORE you leave your existing job. What could possibly be so damn disgusting to you about this?
- nitrogen 11y agoI think they find it disgusting because all the risk is shifted onto the employee. By the time 3-8 weeks have elapsed, the employee has definitely quit or lost their previous job, so if they don't get hired, they will be involuntarily unemployed, with no prospects because they've been busy with their "audition".
- EGreg 11y agoI think the problem is that full-time employment and everything around it is like keeping animals in a zoo. You hope and beg for vacation time. You pretend to work 8 (actually 10 to "look good") hours even if you finish all your work in 1. The most personal work you can hope to retain after you leave, beyond a blurb on your resume is to sneak around behind your employer's back and work on your own stuff. There is tons of politics. The salary negotiation is itself about trading getting the employer to basically take care of you (especially in Japanese corporations, as patio11 often mentions) so you can reduce your risk. The infantile mentality inculcated in people receiving conditional welfare is present in FTE -- pg's essay about schools and jails would be applicable here. One can even argue that our education system has been designed to prepare the majority for being obedient and loyal FTE workers. http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html I'd rather society replaced all this with an UNCONDITIONAL basic income for everyone and everyone would be free from any age to work as a self employed contractor. That would effectively abolish the minimum wage and let people learn through doing projects where they are treated with respect, not as animals in a zoo. I think libertarians talking about philosophical freedoms should take a serious look at actual personal freedom as defined by the range of options each person has.
- lliamander 11y ago> You pretend to work 8 (actually 10 to "look good") hours even if you finish all your work in 1. Maybe my experience isn't representative, but at my job there is actually work to do: you know, hard problems that take time to think through and solve. > The infantile mentality inculcated in people receiving conditional welfare is present in FTE Substitute "conditional welfare" with "earned compensation". How is it infantile to voluntarily negotiate compensation with someone for whom you will be providing value (ie. your employer) and yet not infantile to demand unconditional welfare from society as a whole?
- progressive_dad 11y agoWhat's disgusting is the misuse of the "contractor" designation just as it is with Uber or Instacart. When I work as an independent contractor I do so knowing that I am paying significantly higher taxes on that income, paying for my own health insurance, and managing my time in such a way that I can stay sane. I charge accordingly. Is this company going to pay me the hourly rate they charge their clients during this "trial" period? Are they going to pay me extra because I'm working 40 hours a week and then doing this work overtime? Because if not they are eventually going to find themselves on the wrong end of a lawsuit where they must designate these people as part time employees. I've done an "interview" like this before, but it was 3 months not 3 weeks and they paid me my agreed upon contract rate up front for 15 hours a week work from home. They made a decision not to hire full time after the second month and let me know, but used my additional month of work. I was able to use the time and money to find a full time position during this period that was a good fit. That's fair.
- qmalzp 11y agoAm I the only person who thinks algorithmic/big O puzzles are kind of fun? Like they're super high stress when you're interviewing, but basically everything is super high stress when you're interviewing.
- rdtsc 11y ago> Am I the only person who thinks algorithmic/big O puzzles are kind of fun? They are fun. So company ends with a lot of people who can implement red-black trees and so on, especially under high stress. That could be good in some case. I can't see it that good in general. "So customer reports server keeps restarting every Thursday, can you take a look?" "I am not sure how to do it, but I can invert a binary tree in under 10 minutes though, would you like to see that?"
- dominotw 11y ago>am not sure how to do it, but I can invert a binary tree in under 10 minutes though Most ppl completely forget how to invert a binary tree in about 1 week after the interview. Which makes the whole interview process based on that stuff even more absurd.
- geebee 11y agoThey are kind of fun. I enjoy the problems in "Cracking the coding interview". In fact, preparing for a google interview (no offer) actually reminded me of why I like programming so much. You need to think deeply and creatively about interesting problems, rather than spending all day trying to figure out how to fix "errno 64: gcc header missing"… My misgiving about these interviews is that they are really exams, without the examiner/examinee accord that I think slowly evolved over time, in institutions that are exam-heavy, to provide balance and fairness to both sides. Think about exams at a university: most (but not all) of the time, formal exams come with a number of rights for the person taking the test. It must be consistent, it must be graded fairly, it can't be capricious, it must be related to the coursework, if you fail, you have the right to know why you didn't pass, you get feedback, you get a lasting credential, you have a "study path", and you have a grievance process if you feel things were biased, unfair, or inappropriate. I understand that companies are tight lipped because of liability issues, this means applicants take a high stress five hour exam, but with nearly no feedback. Supposedly there are numerical scores in a database about candidates, but they are not allowed to know what those scores are. Unfortunately, I do think this amounts to an exam without the rights that evolved over time to make sure the process wasn't excessively abusive to people who sit for exams. Lastly - I tend to agree that a company is free to set up what hiring process it likes, within limits. If a month long paid audition/consulting gig is how they'd like to do this, and they accept that this means they will lose out on people with stable jobs (often people with children or other dependents), that's fine. But what do you think about companies that do this but then start complaining to congress that there is a terrible shortage of workers? Should we take them seriously?
- DamnYuppie 11y agoI don't believe anyone is being treated poorly here. They are being paid for their time, worst case the individual could think of it as side work. I understand many people have family and commitments but I don't think this is unreasonable. You are after all given a choice in the matter. The follow up argument is of course, feel free to insert exaggerated hysteria here: "what if everyone moves to this model"? There are worse things in the world then getting paid to interview with someone.
- akerro 11y agoOffense is taken, not given. I can't see where is that humiliation you're talking about. I would take such interview with smile. I think it's good idea. Why don't you?
- brooklyndavs 11y agoCompletely agree. Do accountants have to work on the companies books for 8 weeks as a "trial period"? Does a mechanical engineer have to build widget X on the spot during the interview process? No, for most jobs they look at your background, talk to you about your experience, talk to your references, etc. And if they don't work out, even after some coaching and career development? Lay them off. And don't give me xyz about how hard it is to fire someone. Owners with people working for them in other professions don't seem to have this problem and they lay people off at will. I know that owners and funders are trying to reduce risk as much as possible and this is one way they feel like they can. However, as the article even states, startups fail for all sorts of reasons. Newsflash, staring and running a company is a risky thing to do! Thats why if you succeed there is a large reward!