8 ms·
How Single Women Are Changing Society
- bigpoppa 11y agoin a big way, the increase of single women are reducing adultery rates.
- dang 11y agoPlease stop posting unsubstantive comments to HN.
- marodox 11y agoWhy does the article only focus on single women? For every single women, there exists a single man. Is it because it is seen as socially acceptable for men to lead single lives while not so much for women? Edit: My questions sounds kinda rhetorical. I'm genuinely curious.
- zck 11y ago> Why does the article only focus on single women? Because it's worth investigating subgroups, so we can understand whether society treats those groups differently from other groups -- and if so, how.
- marodox 11y agoI guess I'm just used to all those Japanese articles about their growing single working culture. Those usually focus on how both sexes are giving up relationships in favor of their careers.
- nibs 11y agoNot entirely. Depending on the country, there is often a gap between the number of men and women. Mortality for young men in some countries is still much higher than women (ie. Russia). [1] By 65, there is less than 0.5 men per woman. And even at 15-64 age range, it is 0.9 men per woman. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Russia#Sex_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Russia#Sex_rat...
- return0 11y agoI think because it's more likely women will become single mothers than men becoming single fathers.
- gsibble 11y agoFor every single mother there is a single father.
- duaneb 11y agoBiologically, perhaps. Not legally. Custody battles settle this rather emphatically.
- return0 11y ago> In 2006, 12.9 million families in the US were headed by a single parent, 80% of which were headed by a female. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_parent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_parent
- aikah 11y ago> In 2006, 12.9 million families in the US were headed by a single parent, 80% of which were headed by a female. > 45% of single mothers are currently divorced or separated Which means that potentially 45% of these 80% had the father in court fighting for his kids custody, and we all know how biased to justice system is toward men in that case. My point is don't make it sound like fathers just abandon their kids.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Which means that potentially 45% of these 80% had the father in court fighting for his kids custody No, it doesn't. (Divorce/separated is irrelevant to that, since parental rights for both parents generally exist from birth regardless of marriage so long as paternity is established, and so separation or divorce from marriage is not a prerequisite to custody proceedings. The "potential" number is much higher; though the actual number is lower.) > and we all know how biased to justice system is toward men in that case. Yes, courts are substantially biased in favor of men in contested custody cases; men end up with custody less often in divorce because men are less likely to seek custody. > My point is don't make it sound like fathers just abandon their kids. Unfortunately, the fact is that fathers, all too often -- both without marriage and when it fails -- just abandon their kids.
- duaneb 11y ago> Is it because it is seen as socially acceptable for men to lead single lives while not so much for women? This assumes that society is the only variable in being single. I'm guessing this is not the case. If I were to hazard a guess, the tact was chosen because there's been an uptick in single women (notably, for the first time in US history, more adult women are single than married). There are other facets to look at, but this might be the most visible in terms of expected social change from the feminist perspective I was brought up with.
- retbull 11y agoOr its simply isn't about single men. Who cares if it is only about them not every other group has to be mentioned in every post even if they also have a stake in the discussion. I can write an article about the issues of db optimization without saying a single word about MySQL. Same situation.
- bradleyjg 11y agoMostly because there's a big marketing push behind the book "All the Single Ladies" which recently came out. Either this article was pitched by Simon & Schuster's PR team or it is lucky free publicity generated in response to the buzz created by the other articles successfully pitched by them. A mid to high six figure book advance is really high for a non-fiction book these days. They are hoping they have a blockbuster on their hands.
- phkahler 11y ago>> Why does the article only focus on single women? Because she thinks that women should live independently of men. She thinks we should restructure society and the way we raise children around that notion.
- emodendroket 11y agoWe can ask questions about why it happened and whether it was positive, but the ship has already sailed.
- facepalm 11y agoBecause the author is a single woman who wants to sell her book. Actually there are already lots of people living as singles, and there isn't really that much of a pressure to get married. She is building up a straw man to make her book seem more important.
- te_chris 11y agoWhy does every article like this inevitably lead to men wondering why it's not about them? (I'm a man).
- marodox 11y agoI just curious with this article specifically because its about the idea of the classic heterosexual relationship, which is inherently about men and women. It just seemed it was missing 1/2 of the story.
- Frozenlock 11y agoIt does sound rhetorical. A more 'honest' approach would be "Is it because it is more socially acceptable for one sex to lead single lives, not so much for the other?" I don't really see why you'd assume that women are more frowned upon in this situation. I mean, there's even a picture of SUPERWOMAN in this article! And yet, your initial position was to think that women were the 'victims' here. (For lack of a better word.) Interesting, isn't it? If anything, single women are shown as courageous and going against the tides. If a man decides to lead a single live, he is not seen as a hero. At best it's inconsequential, at worse he's a loser. And this tendency of inconsequential/loser for the men applies to many situations.
- zxcvvcxz 11y agoTo give another perspective, let's examine some of the negatives associated with single motherhood: http://www.photius.com/feminocracy/facts_on_fatherless_kids.html http://www.photius.com/feminocracy/facts_on_fatherless_kids.... As someone who grew up in a single mother home, with many friends in the same boat, anecdotally I can say that it is not preferable in any way. Hypothesizing an evolutionary basis for this, I would say that high investment dual parenting has been the most effective method of raising successful and productive children. Societies which embraced this as the norm have flourished - others, not so much. For more on this topic, see J.D. Unwin: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._D._Unwin https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._D._Unwin
- Retric 11y agoPrior to modern transportation it was common for men to be out of touch with there wives for long periods of time (months / years). So, defacto most society's dealt with lots of single mothers. The classic solution was large extended family's which is where America falls down. PS: It's even a major plot point in the Odyssey which is ~2,800 years old.
- zxcvvcxz 11y agoThere's a substantial difference between a few months (or even years) of deployment vs. 18 years of child development with no father. Also interesting to note is that a lot of negative children statistics do not apply to single mother widows.
- koolba 11y ago> Also interesting to note is that a lot of negative children statistics do not apply to single mother widows. Selection bias?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> As someone who grew up in a single mother home, with many friends in the same boat, anecdotally I can say that it is not preferable in any way. I've never been there. But from my outside perspective, I would think that it might be preferable to abuse, though maybe not preferable to almost anything else. > I would say that high investment dual parenting has been the most effective method of raising successful and productive children. I think that "high investment" is an important note. Even in dual parenting situations, the temptation is to want parenting to be low-investment. (I'm a parent; I definitely struggled with that.)
- return0 11y agoIt's not voiced by the author, but the article makes a case for communal raising of children, which doesn't sound like a bad solution.
- frozenport 11y agoExcept when you consider the poor state of our inner city public schools.
- fiatmoney 11y ago"Communal" being in this case "government". "the democrats should be beating down their door, promising to wash their cars, watch their kids"
- return0 11y agoNot necessarily. it may be an arrangement that springs up locally.
- kough 11y agoWhen I was much younger my parents belonged to a "play group", where parents would take turns baby sitting each others children. Simple printed cards were "paid" each visit and could be redeemed upon other visits. It worked out pretty well and we kids all got to play together. One astonishing outcome: I'm still good friends with someone I met before I have any conscious memory. Kind of cool, right?
- berman 11y agoThe title is "How Single Women Are Changing Society"... Where is the question answered? Oh, I see, here: > Their impact on politics could in theory be tremendous.
- emodendroket 11y agoThis analysis seems awfully shallow. What about their economic situations? I remember reading a lot of pieces cheering the rise of the female breadwinner, but many of those cases involved the man simply losing his job and the woman keeping the same, lower-paying one she had before. Are we just painting a happy and progressive veneer on the same sort of economic decline? It's curious that this is not even mentioned as a factor when they talk about living situations.
- f34fq34f 11y agoChildren from single-parent families are more likely to have problems in future with education, income, criminality... In other words if you correct for single parents, differences between races disappear.
- FussyZeus 11y agoI would postulate that any arrangement where the parents, regardless of number, can be happy and productive is an arrangement that results in a happy and productive child. Instead of studying the various methods and deciding which one is best as though it would make a single difference to the people at large (as if there are people planning their lives by the statistical "best life", whom we should probably ship to Area 51 since they are clearly not human) how about we just agree to all mind our own damn business and let people live how they want to live, with a spouse of the sex and color they prefer, or none at all, with 6 children or with none, and just get on with our lives?
- awl130 11y agothe author is mistaken: single womanhood is not necessarily where female empowerment, or america, is headed. quite the opposite actually. women in scandinavia have been actively decoupling child-bearing from marriage for decades now, and the results are somewhat counterintuitive: marriage rates have been increasing, and at an earlier age[1], because scandinavian women have less concern about balancing career with bearing offspring given all the social and governmental support they now receive. scandinavia has been a leading indicator of almost every social trend (and concomitant government policy) in north america: relaxation of gender roles, women in the workforce, women in politics, decline of marriage, increase in co-habitation, social services for women, etc. every other indicator is as expected: scandinavia's female workforce participation is higher, women in government is higher, etc. however there is one cautionary indicator that is lagging in scandinavia, and that has to do with women in leadership roles in business. one possible explanation is that scandinavian businesses, especially global ones, are privy to the international market. thus while scandinavia may comprise the most liberal countries in the world, their business leaders are competing against foreign businesses, some from developing countries, that are hungry and could give a f* about gender politics. [1]http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/Marriages_and_births_in_Sweden http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/...