4 ms·
> Using screens to hide the identity of auditioning musicians increased women's probability of advancing from preliminary orchestra auditions by fifty percent.
by criddell 11y ago
> Using screens to hide the identity of auditioning musicians increased women's probability of advancing from preliminary orchestra auditions by fifty percent.
I thought that the increase was largely attributed to more women being willing to audition anonymously?
> if that describes you, and you have serious Linux, Ruby, and JavaScript chops, perhaps you should email me
I don't know why, but I always thought the Atwood was 100% invested in Microsoft technologies. Not that it matters, it just surprised me.
Speaking of Atwood, has anybody ever used one of his keyboards? Any opinions?
- emodendroket 11y agoWhy would professional musicians be unwilling to audition in a non-anonymous situation? That sounds quite dubious to me.
- criddell 11y agoI had to Google for it and I don't have the story right. Claudia Goldin was one of the authors of this study: https://www.aeaweb.org/articles.php?doi=10.1257/aer.90.4.715 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles.php?doi=10.1257/aer.90.4.715 She was able to attribute 25% of the increase in hiring of women by orchestras was due to the blind auditions. She also found that there was an explosion of auditions when orchestras adopted the blind format. So it had an effect, just not as large as I thought.
- emodendroket 11y agoOK, perhaps so. But still, the 25% figure shows a large bias against hiring women (which is the conclusion of the study you have linked as well).
- criddell 11y agoYes, I agree.
- Grishnakh 11y agoThat's weird. From what I've seen of women in classical orchestras, if I were the one in charge of auditioning and hiring musicians (not blind), I'd probably be hiring mostly women.... Honestly, if you're a straight guy, why wouldn't you want pretty young women working with you?
- emodendroket 11y agoI'm not sure hiring women with the aim of sexually harassing them is really what we're all talking about.
- Grishnakh 11y agoHey, I'm just pointing out that this common trope about men discriminating against women for jobs doesn't really make that much sense, unless all the men in charge of hiring are gay (which obviously isn't the case or the claim). Seriously, what kind of straight man only wants to be around men all day long, and then (assuming he's married) come home every day to the same woman, and never get to socialize with any other women? Maybe a religious fundamentalist, but not any normal man.
- Grishnakh 11y agoI love how assholes just down-mod me, but no one actually has any kind of reasonable response or refutation.
- emodendroket 11y agoWell, there are a few responses: 1. Why should women be judged on attractiveness? Men are not generally judged on this standard to join orchestras or do office work. It also, perversely, punishes women for being experienced while men benefit from it, handicapping their lifetime earning power. Professional women probably do not want to spend their lives judged as eye candy. 2. Because of the first point you will still end up with a strong male bias on top of whatever natural one training creates; after all, we're looking at men of any age versus young women, for the most part, in this scenario. 3. The numbers clearly do not bear out the assertion you're making in the first place, since blind auditions significantly increase the likelihood of women being hired after auditioning. It seems your "self-evident" reasoning does not fit the facts. 4. I do not think it is true that all men want to spend more time socializing with women. I don't see how the logic you're positing works unless sexual harassment is just outright permitted. If you're not convinced that sexual harassment is bad then I guess you're operating on a different plane than most of us.