5 ms·
The courts have already ruled that code is speech. In Universal City Studios, Inc. v. Corley (the case about the DVD decryption tool DeCSS), the Court of Appea
by leereeves 11y ago
The courts have already ruled that code is speech.
In Universal City Studios, Inc. v. Corley (the case about the DVD decryption tool DeCSS), the Court of Appeals stated:
> Computer programs are not exempted from the category of First Amendment speech simply because their instructions require use of a computer.
> we join the other courts that have concluded that computer code, and computer programs constructed from code, can merit First Amendment protection, although the scope of such protection remains to be determined.
But First Amendment protections are not unlimited. The court ruled in that case (and others) that:
> the scope of protection for speech generally depends on whether the restriction is imposed because of the content of the speech. Content-based restrictions are permissible only if they serve compelling state interests and do so by the least restrictive means available. A content-neutral restriction is permissible if it serves a substantial governmental interest, the interest is unrelated to the suppression of free expression, and the regulation is narrowly tailored, which "in this context requires . . . that the means chosen do not ‘burden substantially more speech than is necessary to further the government's legitimate interests.'"
- ethbro 11y ago> Content-based restrictions are permissible only if they serve compelling state interests and do so by the least restrictive means available. To me, the EFF's argument is more perpendicular to this. They're not arguing about restriction / suppression of free speech, but rather noting that requiring Apple to create, disseminate, and sign an iOS version amounts to compelling speech. From looking at case law (ianal), this looks murky. Commercial speech (which this would be) has a history of being subject to a different interpretation of free speech than individual. The obvious example is cigarettes: the government compels private cigarette companies to include warnings on their product packaging for the good of the state. The twist here is the all/nothing nature of certain encryption questions. Ultimately, we're going to get back to the Clipper Chip, Round 2 and whether private companies have the right to create a system even the government can't breach.