4 ms·
> You may be right, but a good sign for whom, exactly? For the people who lost their jobs? For shareholders? For fans of IBM the company? For IBM. For sharehol
by rdtsc 11y ago
> You may be right, but a good sign for whom, exactly? For the people who lost their jobs? For shareholders? For fans of IBM the company?
For IBM. For shareholders. For people who are not laid off and still work there.
> it's not the fault of the people who are being affected by this, as by and large they were not responsible for IBM's decision to get more and more into support and services.
Is it surprising that IBM is not a flat organization / meritocracy where regular employees get to vote on corporate strategy. Yes it is not their fault. So what should IBM do? They can provide severance packages, extra benefits maybe. Try to re-train some people perhaps. But can't keep everyone till retirement just to provide jobs (That is what Uncle Sam does).
> Why is it that when IBM made a bet that did not play out, that they have cut people's severance benefits signifcantly?
But it did play out. Services was bringing a huge amount of money during late 90s early to mid 2000s. It just doesn't anymore
> Why are we not holding IBM up to be responsible for the well-being of their workers?
We are posting on HN right. This startup land. Every 9 out of 10 startups will die. Are you holding them just as responsible? Or is there some implicit assumption that if you work for IBM then you'll be good till retirement.
> I am arguing that we shouldn't talk about layoffs as a "good sign",
I still argue it is a good sign. It is good for some parties (I enumerated a few above) and it really sucks for those getting laid off. No denying that. Hopefully they could have extra time, severance packages and so on to help.
How about this, what would you do if you ran IBM and you ended up with 50000 employees trained to do something that just doesn't bring profit anymore?
- revelation 11y agoA company is it's employees. If IBM still has cheese slicer designers in 2016, it's because they failed to train them. The discussion we're having here is because there seem to be no repercussions to their failure.
- gozur88 11y agoNo, actually a company is its shareholders. Literally. Employees are the hired help.
- metaphorm 11y agoshareholder capitalism is a noxious falsehood that has very unfortunately been enshrined in our current interpretation of the law. this should not be regarded as a baseline truth nor a desirable transitional state. it is a bad idea that we must not succumb to. companies are multi-faceted entities with many different stakeholders. the workers are a 100% necessary stakeholder and the company cannot operate without them.
- gozur88 11y agoAnd... so what? Sure, the company needs employees, but it doesn't need the people who are there. What's noxious is the whole idea of "stakeholders", as if working somewhere gives you some kind of ownership. If you want to own your job you need to be self employed. If I hire someone to cut my grass is he now a "stakeholder" who needs to be consulted when I sell my house?
- metaphorm 11y agoyour house is not a company. your lawnmower is not an employee, he's a vendor.
- gozur88 11y agoI own my house, the same way I would own a company. And I pay the lawn guy to do a job. I don't see the big difference.
- metaphorm 11y agoits really kind mind blowing to me that you don't see a difference but I'll spell it out for you. a company is an organization of humans. a house is an object. You purchase a service from the lawn care vendor. You are their customer. You are not the employer of the guy who mows the lawn. That guy is either self-employed or he might be the employee of a lawncare company.
- rdtsc 11y ago> A company is it's employees But they are not the same group of employees though ;-) that's the point. > The discussion we're having here is because there seem to be no repercussions to their failure. Ok and how should we punishing all the failed startups though? Who is holding them responsible for their failure? > it's because they failed to train them We should try. But in general this is like the idea of "Why don't we just retrain all the coal miners to write web apps?" The reality is that you can't retrain everyone. Some of the programming stuff seems easy to programmers for example, because well, we forgot the time when we didn't know it yet. But it is not something you can take a few night classes and read a book or two and get to writing back-end services.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoWhen a startup fails, the management are generally out of work as well.
- rdtsc 11y agoNot sure if that brings any comfort to the workers. They still lost their job. Most owners just turn around and do another startup and so on. Should they be punished and held responsible for it somehow. For hiring and then making bad decisions and failing.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>The discussion we're having here is because there seem to be no repercussions to their failure. What do you mean? There are massive layoffs, a falling share price and lots of bad press. What other "repercussions" should there be? Should the government come in and shut the place down? Should it force IBM to keep all employees? Again, what sort of "repercussions" should a company have when they make bad business decisions? The shareholders and employees have suffered, that's the punishment.
- mattzito 11y agoOookay, so to dig into it: > They can provide severance packages, extra benefits maybe. Try to re-train some people perhaps. But can't keep everyone till retirement just to provide jobs (That is what Uncle Sam does). Right, but they cut their severance packages. So clearly they're trying to contain costs. So yes, that's also a good sign for IBM the corporation, less good for their employees. > Services was bringing a huge amount of money during late 90s early to mid 2000s. It just doesn't anymore Now we have to step into the realm of the possible. Would it have been possible for IBM to look at their services backlog and contract timeframes, churn/retention rates and a few years ago say, "Shit, these contracts don't work out from an economic perspective, and maybe we should start to attrition out these deals because they're not going to work out long term?" Maybe someone did (in fact, I'm almost certain someone did somewhere). But I'd also bet that some execs somewhere decided to keep going, keep signing money-losing contracts, that everyone started to live a lie so that they can get promoted, keep their bonuses, etc. And now that they've now decided it was a mistake- the company doesn't pay the price (reduced severance), it's the workers who do. > We are posting on HN right. This startup land. Every 9 out of 10 startups will die. Are you holding them just as responsible? Or is there some implicit assumption that if you work for IBM then you'll be good till retirement. So, I've had to lay people off at a startup. It's terrible. We went out of our way to take care of them, including offering long severance packages, and cutting salaries and bonuses at an exec level to mitigate the layoffs. It sucks, but that was our obligation. And I do hold startups somewhat responsible, but its also a different scenario - early stage startups are a known risk. The big point I want to highlight is that I believe employers have an obligation to look after their employees, and when as a corporation they made a bet that didnt' work out, or had a profitable business that is no longer profitable, the ethical obligation is on them to look after those employees. > How about this, what would you do if you ran IBM and you ended up with 50000 employees trained to do something that just doesn't bring profit anymore? Treat them with dignity. Pay them a lot of money based on their time of service. Recognize that we should see this as a failure as an organization. Never refer to it as a "good thing" EDIT: I also would have tried to "get out in front of it" - 50,000 people's jobs don't become redundant overnight other than through wishful thinking on leadership's part.
- rdtsc 11y ago
- whybroke 11y ago>How about this, what would you do if you ran IBM and you ended up with 50000 employees trained to do something that just doesn't bring profit anymore? Apparently, if you are IBM, you fire them and hire H1Bs http://data.jobsintech.io/companies/ibm-corporation http://data.jobsintech.io/companies/ibm-corporation
- OpenDrapery 11y agoMassive layoffs are not good for the people who remain at the company. It is a major drag on overall morale, and how does one who survives round one of layoffs ever have any piece of mind that s/he won't be next?