4 ms·
This is an amazing comment - yet it really illustrates how fucked up the situation is. It's become a catch-22, and there is no longer any way out.... We are n
by samstave 11y ago
This is an amazing comment - yet it really illustrates how fucked up the situation is.
It's become a catch-22, and there is no longer any way out....
We are now beholden to the situation forever. And to worsen the dynamic, Israel is an AMAZING producer of tech. And as we all know tech is the lifeblood of the future.
There is no way to extricate ourself from this situation, however that does not invalidate the frustration of it.
We need to recognize that Israel is an actual powerful economy, and we need to find a way to let them stand on their own, and not literally being the big brother ready to punch out any bully at school.
The fundamental fact is that Israel should have never become a nuke power. Ever.
That's the hand that has us by the balls.
- dogma1138 11y agoUS military aid to Israel is less than 10% of Israel's GDP, most of those 3 bln. can only be used to buy US made equipment so cutting 3 bln. $ would mean that those 3 bln. are gone from the US defense industry not the other way around. >The fundamental fact is that Israel should have never become a nuke power. Ever. That's the hand that has us by the balls. Israel hasn't even attempted to deploy nukes in 1973 where the situation was almost dire, It's quite unlikely that it will ever use them under any circumstance other than retaliation (and even then it's some what doubtful). You make it sound like Israel is blackmailing the US it doesn't, the US knows that if it cuts the ties between the defense industries it will have both another competitor (Israeli arm deals have to be approved by the US congress since the Chinese Phalcon incident) and it will push Israel to both China and Russia and the last thing that the US wants is open and unrestricted technology sharing between those countries. Israel isn't Pakistan it's not an open nuclear state which parades it's nukes and is a bad day away from becoming a nuclear armed Taliban. While I agree that nukes in the middle east aren't the best idea with recent events vis a vis the Iranian nuclear deal there is no way now for Israel to officially join the NPT and be on a path for disarmament, and as far as nuclear arm races in the ME goes Israel is not now and never has been a factor. Iraq wanted nukes to nuke Iran, Saudi Arabia now wants nukes to counter Iran, Iran wants nukes to be a regional super power.
- samstave 11y agoI really appreciate your input! But I have to ask you; everyone defends the status quo wrt paying this money to Israel, give me an alternative as to how to not do this???
- dogma1138 11y agoWell the money that is paid to Israel is due to the Camp David accords both Israel and Egypt get the same military aid package. The US from time to time allocates additional funds to Israel to fund various R&D programs in most cases they either end up buying into the same equipment and when they aren't they get the technology. If you take out the military aid to Israel and Egypt the US will still continue to fund research out of pure self interests. The director of the MDA once called Israel the US's most cost effective and efficient defense contractor he also said: "The design of Arrow 3 promises to be an extremely capable system, more advanced than what we have ever attempted in the U.S. with our programs"[0] The development of the Arrow 3 started in June 2009 at a total buy-in cost of about 300M, David's Sling was developed in under 5 years for the cost of 250M $, the costs of the SM-3 program so far are estimated at about 15 bln. $ it's land based version Aegis Ashore has already cost over 2 bln. without being fully operational. If you look at it from a pure financial POV if you want to actually save money just delegate all of the US R&D at least as far as Missile Defense goes to Israel, they'll deliver on time and on a budget that most US defense contractors would claim is too small to develop a new shoe lace. [0]http://defense-update.com/products/a/arrow3.html http://defense-update.com/products/a/arrow3.html
- samstave 11y ago>* cutting 3 bln. $ would mean that those 3 bln. are gone from the US defense industry not the other way around. * I literally do not see a problem with this. How about we take the $3bn for defense and invest in infra, edu or argri-tech instead?
- rrggrr 11y agoPointless exercise not just because that ship sailed long ago, but because a nuclear Isreal was (and is) a proxy for US power in the Middle East. Nuclear weapons most of the time prevent more conflict than they create. That may not be the case for much longer, though not by Israel's doing. The better question, one I tried to answer, is the 3b well spent? From my answer and the others the answer is yes on economic and global stability grounds.