3 ms·
Read option B more carefully. The requirement is NOT that you have to give out source code to anyone who asks. It is that the written offer you give out can b
by btilly 11y ago
Read option B more carefully.
The requirement is NOT that you have to give out source code to anyone who asks. It is that the written offer you give out can be used by anyone. Did BMW hand out a written offer with the car that says how to get source code? If so, then it is fine if that offer requires you to enter a piece of information like a VIN.
BMW is under no obligation to hand out written offers to random strangers. You'll have to find someone who bought a car to get an offer.
Now why would BMW set things up this way? Well it is unlikely that all cars have the same exact source code. So without the VIN, BMW doesn't even know which copy to give you! So what are they going to do when someone shows up, is rude, clearly doesn't have the offer in hand, and then demands source code? Apparently they are going to tell him that he needs a VIN.
- tzs 11y agoLet D be the distributor, C be their customer, and T be a third party. The language of 3(b) says that D must give C a written offer to distribute the source to any T. I don't see anything in it that says T has to have a copy of the offer. It says "any third party", and unless there is something in the license that restricts this I'd expect a court to go with the normal meanings of "any" any "third party". The GPL FAQ agrees with my reading, saying that "If you choose to provide source through a written offer, then anybody who requests the source from you is entitled to receive it" [1]. I'd say that requiring the VIN number in order to identify which software to provide source for is reasonable and would be allowed by the license. [1] http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html#WhatDoesWrittenOfferValid http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html#WhatDoesWrittenO...
- btilly 11y agoI think we are in agreement, but let me verify. The scenario I outlined does not require possession of the written offer to get source code. Possession of the knowledge in it, yes. But not possession of the offer. In particular it is reasonable to require you to know that you have to provide a VIN number to get the software. It is also reasonable for you to know what number to call, or address to send, or fee to pay, or even what to say to get to someone knowledgeable enough to have a chance of answering your questions. In fact this email thread said that there is a website where you can enter the VIN and get the source code. I doubt it validates that you are who you say you are. If that website is world readable, I'd say that the GPL is satisfied. (The email thread also made it clear that the people who responded from BMW Australia didn't themselves understand the license. But that is no surprise for an odd request of random people in a big company.)