4 ms·
History has proven over and over again that naming and shaming works miracles. Companies that turned a blind eye and were completely unreachable suddenly turned
by lucb1e 11y ago
History has proven over and over again that naming and shaming works miracles. Companies that turned a blind eye and were completely unreachable suddenly turned active and kind just to save their reputation. Going to or even just threatening to go to the media, I know from experience, is indeed productive.
I am really curious where you got the idea that it's counter productive. Asking the conservancy to clean up this dirty work is expensive and takes forever.
- leereeves 11y agoSometimes shaming works, sometimes it doesn't, and sometimes the mob is misinformed and crucifies an innocent.
- lucb1e 11y agoThe customer service rep might be spreading misinformation, true, but without attention or legal actions, odds are high we'd never know. Better put some pressure on them to actually give a true answer than assume they violate the license and quietly let them continue.
- akamaka 11y agoThe problem is when random people from the internet start unwarranted attacks over GPL violations when the problem can be dealt with constructively. The example that pops into my head is the time when some kid start working on a mod to the Quake 3D engine that was possibly in violation of a free software license. Instead of just reporting it to the copyright holder (id Software), they engaged in a campaign of harassment until John Carmack himself came out and told them to stop. It was some seriously shameful shit. Public shaming should be one of the last steps to take. Maybe before starting a lawsuit, or maybe after, that's up for debate, but certainly after other avenues have been exhausted.
- lucb1e 11y agoI see your point but would say there is a difference between a kid and a multinational. The same law rules both but an individual doing this by accident vs. a company doing it due to ignorance (in the best case) is different. The multinational has enough money to defend itself in court, any individual is bound to have less, especially a kid (in your example).
- FireBeyond 11y agoWhat does this person realistically expect to gain by contacting Tier 1 customer service about an issue with -the source code and licensing of an in car entertainment computer-? Now in theory, CS should be "empowered" or able to escalate, but this is juvenile, to me, the very briefest of exchanges and then off to HN and elsewhere with "time for a lawsuit!".