4 ms·
I still think the waste is the elephant in the room. Exactly how is the (indefinite) cost of safely managing it factored into all those kilowatt-hour costs? Doe
by Terr_ 11y ago
I still think the waste is the elephant in the room. Exactly how is the (indefinite) cost of safely managing it factored into all those kilowatt-hour costs? Does it include tax-dollars going to projects like Hanford or Yucca Mountain?
Even if we're now experienced-enough to develop good socio-regulatory systems for day-to-day generation safety and standards, is the same really true for the waste? Our collective record is still a sad tale of fraying "temporary" solutions, leaks, NIMBY reactions, and playing an institutional game of radioactive-hot-potato.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- coin 11y agoThe waste issue has already been solved. You turn it into glass then store it somewhere geologically stable, such as Yucca Mountain. See http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/chapter11.html http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/chapter11.html
- jaskerr 11y agoUmmm, no. Irrational tho' it may seem, local, regional and national resistance has made Yucca Mountain untenable. So we're back to dry cask and concrete, which is not a long term solution.
- pdonis 11y ago> The waste issue has already been solved. Yes, but the solution isn't to store it. The solution is to reprocess it. That's what all the other major nuclear-using countries do. The only reason the US doesn't is politics.
- jeffwilcox 11y agoThe glassification plant at Hanford is just starting to come online, but Yucca doesn't want it. We have a political problem now, not a technical one... and yeah that's going to be a tough one. I wonder how long until someone figures out ways to let a 3rd world country be the deep bore storage place and allow export?
- ceejayoz 11y ago> I wonder how long until someone figures out ways to let a 3rd world country be the deep bore storage place and allow export? I very much doubt that'll happen. Political stability for a waste repository is going to be just as much a concern as geological stability.
- Terr_ 11y agoWhat do you think I was referring to by "playing an institutional game of radioactive-hot-potato"? The places you mention are actually examples of failure.
- eru 11y ago> Exactly how is the (indefinite) cost of safely managing it factored into all those kilowatt-hour costs? Not a problem for an accountant. It's easy to value an indefinite stream of future dollars in present value terms. The UK even has government debt like that, and they trade for finite amounts of money: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perpetuity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perpetuity
- mirimir 11y agoIn other words, the future is worthless ;)
- eru 11y agoOr more technocratic: interest rates haven't vanished, yet.
- mirimir 11y agoBut some do save for retirement, children's education, etc, etc. Even though the present value of all that is ~0. So there's something missing from the accounting perspective.
- eru 11y agoI don't get it. What's your calculation / estimate to get at a present value of ~0 here? Also, different people have different discounting rates they use for planning the future. When I talked about `interest rates' in general, I meant the prevailing interest rates on the market. If your own discounting rate is lower than that, it totally makes sense to save. If your own rate is lower, borrowing is good. (All other things being equal, of course, which they never are.)
- mirimir 11y agoOK, so ~0 was exaggerating. At ~4% annual discount rate, you're looking at 13% for 50 years out. But that assumes that you'll be alive to benefit. Anyway, my point is that accounting calculations tend to justify screwing the future. And that people, when thinking about themselves and their families, typically don't rely solely on accounting calculations.
- Bluestrike2 11y agoGen IV reactors offer a pretty alluring solution to the so-called waste problem. Being able to close the nuclear fuel cycle, and even consume existing nuclear waste from older reactors, would be much more effective than just locking it all away. Right now, we're only using about 5 percent of the energy in nuclear fuel, where we could be looking at something closer to 95 percent. Instead of looking at transuranics as a problem, we should look at them as a resource in themselves in the future.
- legulere 11y agoThey're way too far away. 2030 maybe, 2040 or 2050 more likely. Those are timelines in which we can replace everything with renewables
- astrodust 11y agoIndia figured out how to re-burn used nuclear material in their reactors due to an embargo. Surely the US can figure this out if they had to.
- maxerickson 11y agoBluestrike2 is talking about consuming much more of the spent fuel material than existing reprocessing. India is getting ready to turn on a fast reactor that they can use to produce more fuel: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prototype_Fast_Breeder_Reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prototype_Fast_Breeder_Reactor But I don't think it will be able to consume as much waste products as the Gen IV stuff, it focuses on making more fuel.