3 ms·
Right, but you can't really anticipate all the ways that people might technically comply with a law while eviscerating the purpose of it. So let's say they spe
by SilasX 11y ago
Right, but you can't really anticipate all the ways that people might technically comply with a law while eviscerating the purpose of it. So let's say they specified a minimum price. And then Comcast "complies" by offering the cheap gigabit service, but in order for it to work more than just on Tuesday and Thursday, you have to pay a huge premium.
Okay, so you say it has to be available 24/7 to comply, but then even Google can't meet that so you add another requirement. Or maybe you have to anticipate legitimate cases of hyperinflation...
At some point you have to just step back and say, "stop being a dick, that's pretty clear not what the law meant and you're just abusing it".
- someone7x 11y agoWell put. The edge cases are endless, we need to take a holistic view sometimes.
- mikeash 11y agoYou may not be able to anticipate all the ways people might abuse the law, but you could at least try. It's not hard to realize that if you say that a company can qualify for a tax break by offering a service, and you don't say what sort of price that offer must have, that the company might "qualify" without really offering the service by offering it at a really high price. That doesn't require being psychic, that just requires sitting down and thinking like the "enemy" for five seconds. I agree that at some point you have to step back and say "you're just abusing this," I just think that failing to specify price requirements is way, way, way before that point. And thus I can't agree with calling Comcast's behavior here "abuse." Especially when their price is actually not all that unreasonable.
- SilasX 11y agoFair enough, I agree with that.