3 ms·
This could be done in a legitimate way. Suppose there were an AdFixPlus plugin with the mission of cleaning up advertising on the Internet by making sure every
by skybrian 11y ago
This could be done in a legitimate way. Suppose there were an AdFixPlus plugin with the mission of cleaning up advertising on the Internet by making sure every website conforms to an acceptable advertising policy that forbids intrusive ads. Users install it for free and advertisers pay for it.
It seems like that should be fine so long as both the users and the advertisers know what's going on, and there are alternative plugins with different policies out there.
Websites can forbid to serve users who turn off too many ads and users can refuse to visit websites that serve too many ads. But both sides would gain if some compromise can be reached. So it seems like a competitive market should evolve towards something that looks quite like this, with a middleman of some sort setting some reasonable rules, rather than one side deciding by fiat how it's going to be.
Of course ad networks and publishers do some of this already. They have policies about not accepting all ads. The constant negotiation about which ads are okay to show is part of the reason why Internet advertising is so complicated. But they are less focused on what the user wants since the user can't choose between ad networks; only the advertiser and publisher can.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>forbids intrusive ads. Users install it for free and advertisers pay for it This is a great idea, but eventually comes full circle. Advertisers will pay more to have more access until they push it too far. Then someone builds a meta-AdFixPlus.
- skybrian 11y agoOr alternatively, competition for users (or the threat of it) from some other plugin that does the same job, but better.