3 ms·
Getting a bunch of people with divergent aims to agree on anything is really fucking hard. Introduce cutting-edge technology, vast sums of money and hardheaded
by jdietrich 17y ago
Getting a bunch of people with divergent aims to agree on anything is really fucking hard. Introduce cutting-edge technology, vast sums of money and hardheaded geeks into the equation and it's a miracle we've got this far.
Open standards are good for all of us. Proprietary systems only ever benefit those who own and control them. The W3C is a fallible, flawed organisation performing an utterly sisyphean task and I think we should give credit where credit is due.
In an ideal world, the perfect standards for everything would just magic themselves out of thin air. Unfortunately, we live in a world where big organisations have commercial interests in manipulating and controlling technology to their own ends. We should celebrate that we still have a mostly open web and thank the W3C for getting things done against all odds.
I'm all for a freer, more open approach to web standards, but I understand that realpolitik is a necessary evil. I'm just really happy that I can't remember the last time I saw the words "best viewed on browser x". Those of us who remember using early versions of Firefox are well aware of just how much progress has been made in standards-compliance. If the W3C is becoming unfit for purpose then that's a damned shame, but we shouldn't throw the baby out of the bathwater. Web standards matter, they are the essence of what the web is. I shudder at the thought of returning to the bad old days of <multicol>, <marquee> and ActiveX controls.
- DennisP 17y agoThe IETF does a nice job with a much more open process.
- kinetik 17y agoThe IETF has its own set of problems: http://www.0xdeadbeef.com/weblog/2009/07/royalty-free-codecs-at-the-ietf/comment-page-1/#comment-206483 http://www.0xdeadbeef.com/weblog/2009/07/royalty-free-codecs...
- DennisP 17y agoSo it's not friction-free. Nothing's perfect, but it's still a much more open process, and much more hacker-friendly. IETF produces simpler standards, and the specs are a lot more understandable than the abominations written by the W3C. There's a reason for that.