4 ms·
I call BS on this. It has no usage what so ever. You can't test for success you can only monitor it.
by ThomPete 17y ago
I call BS on this. It has no usage what so ever.
You can't test for success you can only monitor it.
- forcer 17y agoWhy no usage what so ever? Any process of getting user's feedback is better than doing nothing. We are so skewed of using our own apps that we think all is perfect. Nothing ever is. I think its a great idea how to get more usage data. If I try it I will let you know how it went. I am thinking of using some screenrecording software like SilverBackApp to archive and analyze results later when not drunk :) Janusz Founder of http://www.UsabilityTest.com http://www.UsabilityTest.com (free usability testing for web apps)
- Groxx 17y agoInteresting site... if it works like it appears to, I wouldn't be one of the survey testers, but I'm sure it'd nab a lot of people, enough to at least get some ideas. Good luck with it!
- ThomPete 17y agoBecause success is not measured by the usability of your product. There are countless examples of way too complex products that are still successful and almost any successful company you can think of DIDN'T do usability testing. Companies like Amazon do A/B testing, Apple don't do usability testing at all. Usability starts to matter later on, when you can measure on actual customer behavior rather than user opinion. Down vote me all you want. I challenge anyone to prove that usability tests are actually making more successful products.
- shalmanese 17y agoBoth Amazon & Apple do usability testing. Apple doesn't do focus groups which are an entirely different thing.
- ThomPete 17y agoshalmanese Amazon do A/B tests. Apple doing usability tests? Not according to those I know there. Don't you mean testing?
- shalmanese 17y agoAmazon do both A/B testing & usability testing. Apple's own HIG advocates for usability testing: http://developer.apple.com/Mac/library/documentation/UserExperience/Conceptual/AppleHIGuidelines/XHIGDesignProcess/XHIGDesignProcess.html http://developer.apple.com/Mac/library/documentation/UserExp... Do you have a cite that either does not do usability testing?
- ThomPete 17y agoApple advocates it but don't do it themselves. They follow the genius design method. http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/05_12/b3925608.htm http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/05_12/b3925608.... This article doesn't cite it but hint's at it. Which is obvious for a couple of reasons. Apple is paranoid that anything regarding what they work on get's out. and Apple use the Genius design method. Apple do new things not me to products. Other than that you must take my word for it and those I know at Apple. But again if you can find anything that proves that Apple do usability testing then by all means please share. With regards to Amazon. I know that what matters at amazon is A/B testing. http://glinden.blogspot.com/2007/06/ab-testing-at-amazon-and-microsoft.html http://glinden.blogspot.com/2007/06/ab-testing-at-amazon-and... And looking at their checkout process it doesn't look like anything that have been anywhere near a usability test. But you are missing the point here. The companies didn't become successful because of usability testing that is the crux of the matter and the claim behind the 5USD that is wrong. To the extent it testing your product matters you can ask ANYONE. If it is that bad then why spend 5USD on a beer. But most likely it wont be totally unusable and then the actual evidence of usability test having any positive influence on your likely success.
- ynniv 17y agoI notice that you are a design professional and have written lengthy articles on interface design. The point of this article is that buying a handful of beers will improve your product design immensely, when compared to doing nothing at all. It is an amateur move that probably looks useless from a professional standpoint, but like 24-grit sandpaper, makes a rough job look more polished.
- ThomPete 17y agoDo you really think it's that simple? It's not. There is a whole list of issues with asking people about what they think. Again success of a product is not secured by these kind of tests. Sure if you are doing something that is outright useless but then asking anyone (like girlfriend) is enough. What he is suggesting is equivalent of doing code review with a first year programmer. Wouldn't you call BS if I suggested something like that? I am telling you as a professional, that's not any way to go about testing your product. Unless it's outright useless. But then you don't have to spend 5USD on a beer. You can ask ANYONE for free. Opinions are not valuable feedback.
- shalmanese 17y agoYou seem to have a mistaken idea of what user testing is. It's not asking people what they think of this software, it's asking them to perform specific tasks and then observing where they make mistakes or have issues. The benefits of user testing are well documented. You're most definitely in the minority position for claiming this.
- ThomPete 17y agoI am quite aware of what a usability test is as I have spend quite some time observing them. But as I have also learned over the years is that usability test does not equal more successful product. You are welcome to prove the benefits claim. I don't care if you can prove some academic self referencing point about usability testing improving customer sentiment. I care about successful products and there is absolutely nothing that proves that usability tests or the UCD method is better than any other design process. What company's success is based on them doing usability tests. By all means, please share.