3 ms·
Are error oracles why security software nearly always has poor error messages and therefore poor usability? Or is that just tradition?
by skybrian 11y ago
Are error oracles why security software nearly always has poor error messages and therefore poor usability? Or is that just tradition?
- tptacek 11y agoNo, that's just tradition. Error oracles are a crypto thing; the errors don't even need to be exposed to users for them to be a problem (for instance, the Lucky13 TLS attack uses timing to discern exceptions, not actual error messages).
- caf 11y agoWell, at a high enough level there is some connection there. I think everyone can understand why "Error: The fourth character of your password is wrong" is both more "usable" and insecure.
- digi_owl 11y agoA tradition i would love to see go byebye. Had to deal with a program recently that gave "corrupted MAC" error on the server. All searching etc hinted at it being a network issue. Only after having fiddled with the network for ages and getting nowhere did i set up a loopback test and found the same error. Turns out the program i was dealing with was using an old lib.