3 ms·
Paine advocates for roughly 10% of the GDP to be redistributed which indeed works out to $5600 in the US using 2014 numbers. This, however would easily lift a
by aidenn0 11y ago
Paine advocates for roughly 10% of the GDP to be redistributed which indeed works out to $5600 in the US using 2014 numbers. This, however would easily lift a single-earner part-time minimum wage head-of-household of 3 from below the poverty line to above the poverty line ($5600 * 3 = $16800, which is just $3360 below the poverty line of $20160)
- ghaff 11y agoWhile true, many advocates of this sort of plan are arguing for it so that workers don't have to work crappy minimum wage jobs but can go off and do something more creative. Or they can rely on basic income if their jobs are automated away.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> While true, many advocates of this sort of plan are arguing for it so that workers don't have to work crappy minimum wage jobs but can go off and do something more creative. Or they can rely on basic income if their jobs are automated away. I think its not unreasonable to see UBI as something that could enable that, with sufficient growth in productivity driven by automation. I think that its naïve to think that you can set UBI at a level now that achieves that, though. 10% of GDP can provide a lot different living standard as GDP/capita increases.
- aidenn0 11y agoI don't see a politically feasible basic income plan of that scale happening anytime soon. But allowing a single mother to cut hours down to 20-30 hours a week from 50 would be a huge win for quality-of-life. Really, most people who read HN would notice the difference of an extra 5 grand in their pocket each year, and they are on average much wealthier than the people I'm thinking of.
- ghaff 11y agoThe average person who reads HN would almost certainly have >$5K removed from their other pocket to pay for the $5K they would be given. There's no magic source to suddenly give everyone $5K more money--unless you pretend there is and have inflation eat up the whole amount.
- aidenn0 11y agoMy point wasn't that the people on HN would be $5k richer; it was rather that if they would notice $5k, how much more would someone notice who is right around the poverty line.