It doesn't sound like you read Paine's proposal. You're talking more about a collectivism along the lines of Socialism or Communism. That isn't what Paine is

It doesn't sound like you read Paine's proposal. You're talking more about a collectivism along the lines of Socialism or Communism. That isn't what Paine is proposing. Under Paine's system people keep 100% of the fruits of their labor. Compulsion is not needed in order to have basic income. Basic income can be done in a way that is 100% compatible with private property rights and capitalism. Paine was not proposing that we tax income and use that for basic income.