6 ms·
Paine's arguments, which have been widely expanded on by geolibertarians, are compelling but what he's specifically advocating here is most naturally interprete
by notahacker 11y ago
Paine's arguments, which have been widely expanded on by geolibertarians, are compelling but what he's specifically advocating here is most naturally interpreted as extremely limited compared with what developed world governments offer their populace instead.
Fundamentally, he's arguing that people should be compensated to allow them to reach the same standard of living as would have been possible in the absence of civilization and proposing a subsidy in the region of £1000 per annum in today's sterling to compensate. That's far closer to the Alaska Permanent Fund in both ideological underpinnings and magnitude than it is to being an adequate welfare state replacement[1]. Of course, we could speculate that he'd advocate a much higher subsidy in today's land of relative plenty, but his 1797 argument is quite explicit in suggesting that people are owed no more than the value of the life they could have enjoyed in a Native American "state of nature" and the landed classes owe no more than that.
Fortunately today we have new arguments for the economic benefits of universal education and necessity of unemployment insurance in an economy managed to ensure some level of involuntary unemployment persists.
[1]£1k per year for Paine's average 30 year adult remaining lifespan plus £1.5k at 21 is less than my government's investment in my education...
- bcheung 11y agoAs a Libertarian who believes in the Singularity and that the workplace will be displaced by AI I think basic income and the Geolibertarian, Agrarian Justice, Georgism style basic income is the only one that will work and that doesn't violate the principle of liberty and respect for personal property. With Internet based education, society has the potential to make education virtually free since the cost of distribution is essentially zero. It's only when people need access to special equipment or more hands on lab style education where facilities and mentors will be needed. There is still the problem of gentrification though as basic income will be the same everywhere but certain cities will be much more expensive than others. This will lead to skilled labor concentrating in geographic locations.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI think you're wrong about education. The difference between a decent and an amazing teacher can be phenominal, regardless of the syllabus. Plus, the best education is apprenticeship/on-the-job training, which makes humans even more necessary. The more we use technology, the greater the role people become. You can see any video on the Internet, but most of them are trash and a waste of time, so you look to the producers and curators you prefer. "Machines will make everything we want," people in your category tend to say. Yes, but who designs the clothing, and who markets it into your soul to make you feel incomplete without it? Who comes up with the recipes for your gourmet lunchtime subs? Whom do you trust to suggest one vacation locale over an other? Also, cynically put, this kind of societal transformation will require the dominant financial and political classes to willingly bestow the world with their riches, while giving away their power. When in history has that ever happened?
- hfourm 11y agoWell, the important threshold he isn't really commenting on -- but which is much more pertinent, is the further removal of blue collar labor. You are totally right that for the most part, service oriented industries (design, marketing, etc) will remain long after those more labor and autonomous jobs have been transitioned into AI.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI disagree about the "blue collar labor" aspect as well. Aren't many lumberjacks in my neck of the woods these days, but woodworkers aplenty. Let's take another example. Perhaps McDonald's goes 100% automated, and a sub shop next door adopts automations for things like cleaning, but still cooks the food by hand. Sure, it doesn't take too much to make a sandwich, but it's the personal aspect that makes it more appealing. And maybe you go there because you like chatting with the people who work there. Couldn't get the same from a machine. I think before we get ahead of ourselves on AI we should re-read "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?" and remember that the organic will always value the organic more than the inorganic.
- 11y ago
- dilemma 11y ago>With Internet based education, society has the potential to make education virtually free since the cost of distribution is essentially zero. It's only when people need access to special equipment or more hands on lab style education where facilities and mentors will be needed. The "education system" isn't an education system, it is a selection system and its function is almost purely social, filtering most people out of attractive social locations. Additionally, even if the number of engineers doubled overnight, there would not be a proportional increase in firms or jobs because that is not what drives the economy - new initiatives do, and that doesn't come from education (see Schumpeter on the role of the entrepreneur.) Further, as you admit, belief in AI is just that: belief. It is ideology and like religion has nothing to do with science, or reality.
- paulryanrogers 11y agoNot everyone is self motivated or disciplined enough to learn entirely online. Different people also find different learning styles with better for them.
- ctdonath 11y agoFinally, someone recognizes there's a vast range between truly basic income/expenses, vs maintaining a standard of living exceeding the norm of most people on the planet. The US "poverty line" is at the ~80th percentile of world income, and one way or another one below it can get enough aggregate welfare payments to step well above that line. Contrast that with really basic costs of food ($1/meal traditional diet, or $12/day Soylent ready-to-drink), housing (one 100 sq ft simple "tiny house" per person, $1-10/day), data service ($1/day), plus other comparably humble-yet-sufficient services add up to something like $5000/yr (and much less in bulk or with other careful reductions). But that is, of course, outrageous to most BI advocates - viewing "basic" as a complete-and-served product, not a collection of staples requiring the recipient put some real effort into.
- sliverstorm 11y agoPerhaps the beauty of the notion of BI (and thus its growing popularity) is that you can attach whatever level you perceive as basic living expenses. To one man BI is to prevent starvation, to another it's not BI if it doesn't cover at least two car payments.
- mjevans 11y agoDefine car payment; actually please don't, I can't see any point other than inflammation. A 'basic' income should ideally fulfill the basic structural needs of someone living in an area. * Adequate Shelter * Food (possibly basic, but it should be healthy. Food does tend to work better in bulk though, so not-for-profit health kitchens are something I'd recommend) * Health (including cleaning supplies/etc) * Enough whatever (transit, clothing, education, etc) to get a better job. * //basic// entertainment In these last two points I see work uniforms, transit, probably paper/notes, and likely --basic-- computers (think Raspberry Pi 3) with Internet access (generic TV/work). Edited: Added even more newlines
- crdoconnor 11y agoActually if it doesn't do this it would likely just end up acting as a subsidy to low wage employers. Only if it's enough to give people the freedom to walk away from their jobs is it actually meaningful, and realistically it's not going to be introduced at a level where it would.
- my5thaccount 11y agoThis amount of money is not realistic even when you put it into an inflation calculator. For example, Walden built his cabin for $28 in the 1850's, which is about $900 today and clearly not enough to build a cabin with today's dollars even scrapping like he did.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 11y agoThis person claims to have a viable plan to build a replica of Thoreau's Walden cabin for under $1k. http://www.instructables.com/id/Thoreau-Off-Grid-Cabin-Design-Under-900/ http://www.instructables.com/id/Thoreau-Off-Grid-Cabin-Desig... Sure, inflation and purchasing power parity calculations don't always work between very different societies, but if you replace that indicative £1000 sum with "sufficient to ensure you can rent enough land to put a teepee on and buy some of the basic foodstuffs you can't hunt/forage any more" which is what Paine argued civilization had cost the average person, it doesn't start to look like an adequate welfare replacement.
- my5thaccount 11y agoCool, that person's math an mine are the same! :) He does say, "That price does not include windows, door, insulation or interior furnishings. In place of a brick fireplace I have recommended a recycled steel barrel stove and stove kit from Vogelzang that would be more efficient." Those things he is excluding will easily double the price. A wood stove costs thousands, maybe hundreds used. 8 sqft of insulation is $50. Windows are $200 each. A door the same or more. And also, 10'x15' isn't really viable for a home, even for one person, much less a family that wants a shower in the bathroom. We also have building codes now that require a functional kitchen and bathroom which add significantly to the price of a livable structure the government won't tear down. I think bare minimum costs to build a livable structure today, would be in the $50,000 range and the mortgage on that would be $300 per month, which would fit within my proposed living stipend of $2,000 per month per family of 4.
- dilemma 11y agoThis is a very important reminder. All philosophizing about UBI is superfluous because it is impossible to set the level of this "income". Nobody would be satisfied with $2K per person and year; $20K would be too much for any state budget yet too little to live on.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> All philosophizing about UBI is superfluous because it is impossible to set the level of this "income". I disagree that that the difficulty in reaching consensus on the ideal standard of living UBI should provide makes philosophizing about UBI superfluous (in fact, I think that observation is a key part of the philosophizing about UBI, and among the reasons that it should not target a particular living standard; rather, it should be tied to a particular revenue source or set of revenue sources (whether that's a resource extraction charge, a tax on capital income, a land value tax, or some combination thereof), and then simply redistributes the value of that revenue stream among the citizenry on an equal basis. It should be the kind of revenue stream such that the expectation is that with continued technological and economic development, the value (and thus the standard of living it supports) will usually increase over time.
- ghaff 11y agoMoney is fungible however. The government is still in the position where (theoretically) you're somewhat balancing money in and money out. So tie UBI to some specific revenue source or set of sources, and you still need to: 1.) Determine those sources and 2.) The tax rate on those sources. That's still all money that would have gone to different individuals or different uses. It's also subject to future political pressure to change the percentage. So it's not a case of picking source(s) and rate(s) to support an arbitrary payment outcome. Sometimes it is close to the ideal. The Alaskan Permanent Fund probably comes closest in the US. But that's probably not enough for a UBI and it's unclear what the equivalent at the US level would be. In addition, it's likely that anything directly associated with resource extraction would decrease over time.
- ghaff 11y agoI generally agree. I mean you possibly could do it. One could live on a pretty small sum in a non-luxury area of the country. (Forget about the Bay area. Think Detroit.) But it's going to be a pretty minimalist existence and you're probably not going to find a lot of supplemental jobs in such an area.
- dragonwriter 11y agoPhilosophically, its kind of hard to justify a harm based charge (which is what Paine suggest) if you accept otherwise the principles of a free-exchange, market-based economy. It would be just as justifiable to demand a benefit based charge based on what the beneficiaries receive beyond what they would receive in the state of nature, and obviously a fair charge would be somewhere in between those values, such that both those who lose (directly) to privatization of property and those who (directly) gain from it are net winners.