3 ms·
I don't see anything wrong with cure-all massive policy proposals. Some of them have worked in the past. For example, separating from the British Empire, freein
by mikeash 11y ago
I don't see anything wrong with cure-all massive policy proposals. Some of them have worked in the past. For example, separating from the British Empire, freeing the slaves, and ending alcohol prohibition. (That last one has an obvious mirror in starting alcohol prohibition, but my point is just that they can work, not that they all do.) And yes, these all brought problems with them, but they were massive improvements.
I also don't see how this is "how every policy got started." There are plenty of policies that are incremental, evolutionary, and all that.
Obviously, big policy changes need to be approached very cautiously, since the potential for problems is huge. But that means you analyze and consider them carefully, not just say "nope, too big" and shut it down.
- RodericDay 11y agoJacobin had a somewhat interesting piece on Alexander Hamilton vs. Thomas Jefferson a while back (https://www.jacobinmag.com/2014/08/reading-hamilton-from-the-left/ https://www.jacobinmag.com/2014/08/reading-hamilton-from-the...), and the magnitude of policy proposals.
- stvswn 11y agoI don't think this proposal qualifies as "too big to manage." But I disagree with your examples. Freeing the slaves was necessary and proper, but far from immune to the original argument. We screwed it up, big time (I don't mean to start a debate over this one, I think it's fairly uncontroversial that Reconstruction failed in some regards) -- in other words, we can simultaneously argue that sometimes massive policy proposals are correct but they almost always come up short of intention. "Ending slavery" couldn't be accomplished otherwise, but that doesn't meant that it was executed well. Ending Prohibition was the opposite of a "massive policy," as are some other popular deregulations (airlines, electromagnetic spectrum, encryption to name a few). This is the federal government deciding to stop doing something. It's not the case that anyone is arguing "the federal gov't never makes a good decision." Popular government-led programs are usually local or laissez-faire in nature. Public school systems, for instance. Or food stamps, which are relatively simple to execute. Or Social Security. The latter two have the feature that it's the individual's choice of how to spend the money. So national income is a good example of "welfare that isn't centrally planned," and in that regard I believe it has a chance at success. The reason I think it's possible is because you wouldn't need a panel of bureaucrats deciding how to distribute all of the welfare -- you'd simply need to distribute the debit cards or whatever.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Ending Prohibition was the opposite of a "massive policy," as are some other popular deregulations (airlines, electromagnetic spectrum, encryption to name a few). This is the federal government deciding to stop doing something. It's not the case that anyone is arguing "the federal gov't never makes a good decision." Both establishing and ending prohibition were decisions made by the states collectively as overseers of the federal government, not decisions by the federal government; that's how the Constitutional Amendment process works. > Popular government-led programs are usually local or laissez-faire in nature. Social Security and Medicare seem notable counterexamples, neither is local, and neither is laissez-faire. > Or food stamps, which are relatively simple to execute. Or Social Security. The latter two have the feature that it's the individual's choice of how to spend the money. In both cases, I would say they aren't laissez-faire because of the fairly complex regulations determining who gets how much money; and, for food stamps, it also is not true that "it's the individual's choice of how to spend the money", as there are regulations as to what can and cannot be purchased with SNAP benefits.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> Social Security and Medicare seem notable counterexamples, neither is local, and neither is laissez-faire. Medicare and Medicaid are both a lot more laissez-faire than people realize. 40% of all Medicare patients are on Medicare Advantage plans - ie, plans that are privately managed by brand-name health insurers that sell private insurance. And this understates the number of Medicare patients who utilize private insurance in one way or another, because (a) Medicare Advantage patients represent a disproportionate amount of utilization of care by Medicare patients, and (b) some Medicare patients are eligible for dual-coverage (so they "have" Medicare, but they use a privately-purchased health plan for all of their actual medical needs). Incidentally, to address the original argument, Medicare Advantage patients are the ones who report higher satisfaction with their health care.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 11y ago
- ctdonath 11y agoThing is, those examples are quite final: nobody is compelled to continue contributing effort & wealth to maintain them. "Separating from the British Empire"? to wit: get out & stay out. "Freeing slaves"? end legal enablement of slavery. "End alcohol prohibition"? stop enforcing prohibition. Those are VERY different from "basic income", where a government must actively & continuously compel the productive to give up the fruits of their labors for re-distribution to whoever is legally defined as "needy" et al. Were it akin to the Biblical practice of "gleaning" (farmers don't go back to ensure absolutely everything was harvested, leaving that to the needy to scavenge), ok: (US-centric answer) basically open up BLM-managed government-owned property for temporary housing & harvesting, shooing people off yearly or so to ensure no permanent claims & abuse. But such "gleaning" solutions are immediately shot down by BI proponents, preferring solutions which demand nothing of recipients and thereby demand complete care provided by the productive. Massive policy proposals which stop an activity are successful. Those demanding ongoing taxation etc aren't, as they're prone to growing complications & abuse.
- bcheung 11y agoIt doesn't sound like you read Paine's proposal. You're talking more about a collectivism along the lines of Socialism or Communism. That isn't what Paine is proposing. Under Paine's system people keep 100% of the fruits of their labor. Compulsion is not needed in order to have basic income. Basic income can be done in a way that is 100% compatible with private property rights and capitalism. Paine was not proposing that we tax income and use that for basic income.
- ctdonath 11y agoI was responding to the examples of allegedly successful "massive policy proposals", all of which were precisely not collectivism.
- dilemma 11y agoWhat you mention are decisions, not policies. The latter is a decision to end a catastrophic policy, which itself contradicts your claim that such policies can work.
- mikeash 11y agoThe existence of a catastrophic policy does not contradict a claim that such things can work.