3 ms·
Coordination through the market is far from perfect. The market has myopia and rarely makes huge long-term investments, and sometimes it leads people off a cli
by leereeves 11y ago
Coordination through the market is far from perfect.
The market has myopia and rarely makes huge long-term investments, and sometimes it leads people off a cliff like a band of lemmings.
For example, it's given the United States a plethora of entertainment but decaying infrastructure, and the housing and dot-com bubbles.
The best system seems to be a mix of both central planning and private markets.
- icebraining 11y agoThere was (and is) a tremendous involvement of central planning in the housing market, so much that calculating its influence the bubble is impossible. Using it as evidence that we need more central planning is essentially using No True Scotsman - "no, I mean the good kind of central planning". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causes_of_the_United_States_housing_bubble#Government_policies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causes_of_the_United_States_ho...
- leereeves 11y agoWould you agree that the worst abuses (like NINJA loans and selling assets known to be toxic) weren't centrally planned?
- icebraining 11y agoSure. My disagreement, or actually, my skepticism is on whether having "more" centrally planning would have made things better. That idea seems to rely on some utopic visions of the political process, in which the responsible people are not only extremely honest, but also have uncanny foresight.
- leereeves 11y agoI'll grant that - obviously the government failed to prevent the housing bubble - but I think the bubble and the crash were fundamentally driven by market forces. And central planning was essential to the clean up afterwards. I think that supports the idea that a mix of the two is best.
- jazzyk 11y agoThe housing bubble was not driven by market forces. It was driven by central planners by incentivising mortgage companies to lend recklessly, as these companies knew the mortgages were guaranteed by quasi-governmental companies like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac which currently hold ~87% of all mortgages [1]. No wonder the Fed is so keen on pumping up housing prices (through too-low interest rates) [1] http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/06/business/helping-housing.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/06/business/helpi...
- leereeves 11y agoThat link shows that the "share of mortgages backed by the government" dropped during the bubble and fell as low as (about) 38%, and it didn't increase until after housing prices peaked. I think you've misinterpreted the statistic you quoted. During the bubble, lenders found easy money for mortgages from private markets, and it was after the bubble ended that the government stepped in to prop up prices.
- woodandsteel 11y agoI have a couple of questions for you. But first, when the bubble was happening, conservatives said that prices were sound, would never crash, and this was because they were the product of market forces. But then the bubble burst, and overnight conservatives switched to saying it had all been unsound because of government intervention. So let me ask you, what was your position when the bubble was happening, and how did you respond when conservatives suddenly changed their story?
- jazzyk 11y agoWhy do you bring politics into this? This was neither conservative nor liberal bubble. Both sides are guilty, this is central planners vs the market. I saw the bubble for what it was, most of my friends looked at me strangely, thinking I was probably jealous, because I was not interested in buying a $2M shack masquerading as a house.
- coryrc 11y agoThat's not the worst abuse; the worst abuse is studio apartments renting for over $2000/mo.