3 ms·
The US inherited an existing slave regime from the Caribbean. It entailed exactly the same cognitive dissonance required of soldiers in the British Empire as de
by ArkyBeagle 11y ago
The US inherited an existing slave regime from the Caribbean. It entailed exactly the same cognitive dissonance required of soldiers in the British Empire as described by Orwell in "Burmese Days". So it looks Mercantilist to me.
I don't hold that debt is inherent to what we consider capitalism. I run the risk of a "no true Scotsman" fallacy with this, but debt is something we have because of path dependence, not because it's shown to be inevitable or optimal.
The fact that debt cannot be easily retired indicates that we haven't finished this as an institution. At the level of a debt holder, of course you can't do this. At the level of a general person living in society, the un-retire-ability of debt creates a common, sort-of pubic goods problem because it slows growth.
Classical and pre-Classical societies held debt jubilees. Could we? I don't know.
- dragonwriter 11y agoDebt jubilees would be directly contrary to the capitalist conception of property; insofar as it features them, a society has broken with capitalism.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoDebt is an artifact of finance, not of capitalism. If some genius tomorrow announced a way to have money creation without the attendant debt overhang, we'd do that instead. Capitalism would still be exactly the same. Debt precedes capitalism by... the entirety of human history. The map is not the territory and accounting and finance are technologies that attend to productive enterprise, not the enterprises themselves.