3 ms·
Is your issue just that you hate all advertising? If so, shouldn't you take your ire out on the web itself rather than Google, as Google is hardly unique in us
by mike_hearn 11y ago
Is your issue just that you hate all advertising?
If so, shouldn't you take your ire out on the web itself rather than Google, as Google is hardly unique in using advertising to sustain itself. Many websites do.
And what is the alternative? Everyone pays for everything, thus providing bank-authenticated billing data to every company? At least with ad supported services you can use them anonymously, if you want to. Besides, Google has their Contributor product that (in some cases) lets you pay to not see adverts. So it's not like they aren't trying to find a good balance.
Is your issue that you dislike targeted ads specifically?
If so, doesn't the fact that you can opt out of ad targeting and/or edit your own profile change anything? Surely you can see that many people would prefer to see relevant ads rather than ads intended for the wrong gender, age group, regional populations etc?
It's unfortunate that you feel so strongly about something as mundane as online advertising. Google is not the military or the CIA, where the actions of the employees can result in people getting randomly drone striked. It's just a software company.
I say these things because I used to work for Google and the people there are usually very happy. It seems a shame to rule out a company that's always tried so hard to find the right moral balances in things on grounds as flimsy as "advertising sucks".
- stephenr 11y ago> Is your issue just that you hate all advertising? If I'm looking at a site about fish ponds, or gardening, I would absolutely be OK with seeing adverts about where to buy a pond liner, or a contractor who builds fish ponds. I would even be OK with that ad being somewhat location specific based on my IP address. The above situation would have literally helped me in a real word situation in the last month. But, because of the way the vast majority of web advertising works, there was no opportunity, because I have to block ad networks because: I am not ok with seeing ads about "rent a cheap server today" because there's an email from a hosting company in a google apps mailbox, or because I got an email from a client asking about where to host something. That is objectively fucking creepy. > If so, doesn't the fact that you can opt out of ad targeting and/or edit your own profile change anything? This is like the argument that I can go to http://www.networkadvertising.org/choices/ http://www.networkadvertising.org/choices/ and choose to "opt out" of aggressive web tracking. The problem is, it works on a cookie basis, meaning I have to lower my privacy settings for the whole thing to even work, and then hope that some other bad actor doesn't take advantage of that, and that the NAI members even do what they say. Creating a google profile (and being signed into it on every device i use) so I can tell them not to track me when I view sites they don't own/run is fucking ridiculous. > It seems a shame to rule out a company that's always tried so hard to find the right moral balances in things on grounds as flimsy as "advertising sucks". I never said advertising sucks. I said Google are a creepy mega corporation collecting every bit of information they can.
- stegosaurus 11y agoPretty much, yes. I think that accepting advertising as a normal part of life is terrible. I cannot escape from Coca Cola's existence. I cannot, without locking myself in a cabin, ignore corporations, because they shove themselves in my face every day, even if I don't go to the grocery store. I walk down the street and see adverts for beauty products. So I'm reminded that whole industries, thousands if not hundreds of thousands of workers, exist to try and peddle chemicals to the insecure. I do see it as a moral issue. Without a cost-benefit analysis, 'X would not exist without advertising' is a meaningless argument - hell, you can't even show that it's true, plenty of websites exist without advertising. This idea that everything must be 'monetized' is broken. Artists require enough money to live and to buy materials for their art. We can provide that without everyone being encouraged to buy bollocks they don't need.