4 ms·
> Land value tax would replace other taxes such as income tax. Considering 30% of US land is owned by federal government (and there's more by states and munici
by prostoalex 11y ago
> Land value tax would replace other taxes such as income tax.
Considering 30% of US land is owned by federal government (and there's more by states and municipalities), how would this replace the income taxes? Federal budget is comprised of 46% personal income taxes and 13% federal income taxes, so roughly two-thirds of it would have to be replaced by land value tax.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Considering 30% of US land is owned by federal government (and there's more by states and municipalities), how would this replace the income taxes? By taxing the land not owned by the federal government, since obviously it can't tax itself. > Federal budget is comprised of 46% personal income taxes and 13% federal income taxes, so roughly two-thirds of it would have to be replaced by land value tax. So? Look, to replace the entirety of federal revenue (which is more than you need to replace, since obviously things like fees for uses of federal land, which are part of federal revenue, aren't going to go away with a land-use-tax scheme) with land use tax on the 70% of land not in federal use, assuming a flat per-acre tax (which has the virtue of making calculation easy, even if its not the most likely tax scheme), you'd need an annual tax of $3.02 trillion / 1.7 billion acres, or a land-use tax of about $1776 per acre per annum.
- prostoalex 11y agoNot sure about the validity of the research, but entire land value of the US was estimated at $23 trillion http://www.msn.com/en-us/money/generalmoney/what-us-land-is-really-worth-state-by-state/ar-BBkTfZS http://www.msn.com/en-us/money/generalmoney/what-us-land-is-... To extract $3 trillion out of $23 trillion the tax would need to be established at an average 12% annually, which will probably cause some massive repricing.