5 ms·
> This applies to everything else governed by a market, why shouldn't it apply to property taxes? Taxes aren't governed by a market; the same rules don't apply
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
> This applies to everything else governed by a market, why shouldn't it apply to property taxes?
Taxes aren't governed by a market; the same rules don't apply. Arguments against government protectionism in markets don't also apply to protection against the actions of the government itself.
That said, proposition 13 doesn't seem like a good implementation of this. There's no good reason for a sudden increase upon sale; that breaks the ability to buy a home. There should be a hard cap on property taxes that doesn't change on sale.
Why should taxes get to increase without bound or control on existing property? Once you've paid off your home, you should not have an ever-growing expense to keep it.
(You shouldn't have an expense to keep it at all, but that's a separate argument.)
- ryandrake 11y agoProperty taxes are based on property values, which are governed by a market. My view is that property taxes fund the very things that make a particular neighborhood desirable, like good schools, roads, parks, and other local services. Your property's value is what it is because of these things, and you shouldn't be able to reap these benefits without paying taxes proportional to the value you've captured.
- ghaff 11y agoThey typically mostly fund schools, which long-time home owners generally aren't even using. One of the whole reasons to buy property is to have some long-term residential stability, which doesn't happen if property taxes can increase rapidly. If I'm holding onto my home, I've only captured value in a theoretical sense. I don't have any cash to pay for the increased property taxes until I sell.
- prostoalex 11y ago> My view is that property taxes fund the very things that make a particular neighborhood desirable, like good schools, roads, parks, and other local services. I think you're arguing that richer neighborhoods should have nicer schools, roads and parks. Granted, SF is an exception here, but that's precisely how things work elsewhere in California. And if richer neighborhoods don't get that, California made annexations pretty easy, which is why you see those tiny municipalities in the vicinity of Los Angeles, San Diego, Anaheim, etc.
- ryandrake 11y agoI'm arguing that richer neighborhoods DO have nicer schools, roads, and parks. Prop 13 says you may live in such valuable neighborhood while not paying taxes in proportion to that value, merely because you happened to buy a long time ago.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> I'm arguing that richer neighborhoods DO have nicer schools, roads, and parks. That's a really good reason to stop funding those things through property taxes.
- prostoalex 11y agoI an questioning how big of a problem that is empirically. One can't really arbitrage that effectively. Municipalities can't run consistent deficits, so the new schools, roads and parks will be built after a wave of newcomers buys properties, locking in higher prices and higher tax base. In case there are no such newcomers (i.e. everybody is maximizing their Prop 13 benefit by not selling), the municipality just sticks to the last year's budget with a 2% increase permitted by Prop 13. But in that case new schools, parks and roads that make the neighborhood better don't appear either.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> My view is that property taxes fund the very things that make a particular neighborhood desirable, like good schools, roads, parks, and other local services. In California, that's less true than it might otherwise be, given the prop 13 limits on both assessments and tax rates. Lots of those things are funded by sales tax revenue, income tax revenue (primarily state income tax funding local programs), development fees, and other revenue sources other than property tax.