3 ms·
I think that Gassee does not fully appreciate the impact of the independence of U.S. law enforcement and judiciary. Now that it's a court case, it might not be
by snowwrestler 11y ago
I think that Gassee does not fully appreciate the impact of the independence of U.S. law enforcement and judiciary.
Now that it's a court case, it might not be possible for it to be "delicately guided into a marsh of hearings and commissions". Its fate as a court case will be determined by judges, who generally have no interest in careful political management.
If the Justice Department loses, they can choose not to appeal, sure. But that decision will have to come from within Justice. As far as I know, it is illegal for the president to interfere with a criminal investigation.
If Apple loses, they will appeal it all the way to the Supreme Court.
Ultimately the only thing that can short circuit the process now, is Congress.
Maybe that's why the FBI did what they did. As things stood until this case, the default was that companies did not have to help. Congress would have to pass a law to force them to. But if the FBI wins this case, the opposite will be true: Congress would have to pass a law to limit the forced helping.
Betting on Congress is never a good idea, especially these days. So whoever is happiest to ask Congress to the least, often wins. The FBI is betting that there is a chance to flip the script.