3 ms·
> buying land and sitting on it to exploit scarcity creates no wealth. Therefore if you buy lower and sell higher that money comes from wealth created elsewhere
by imgabe 11y ago
> buying land and sitting on it to exploit scarcity creates no wealth. Therefore if you buy lower and sell higher that money comes from wealth created elsewhere, making you a leech. If you buy somewhere to live in, fine, but more than one place to speculate: you are leeching off of the labour of others.
I disagree that this is leeching. For one thing, there's no guarantee the speculator's land is going to go up in value. It could just as easily flatline or decrease.
For another thing someone has to own the land. Whether it's another person or a government. A speculator can't force anyone to sell their land. On the other side of the purchase, there was a previous landowner who wanted to sell. The speculator created a market in which that seller can sell their land. Are you suggesting it should be incumbent upon the seller to discern the motives of every buyer and only agree to sell to someone who's not speculating? How could they? Also, why would they artificially limit their pool of potential buyers? They don't gain anything from that.
The buyer presumably created some value at some point in the past in order to have the wealth to buy the land in the first place. Owning it and maintaining it in a salable condition until someone needs it is a useful service.
- branchless 11y agoLand value tax would see the govt effectively own the land and you own the right to build on it (and to capture the gains made by the building). They keep the value they create, but they pay for the location which has it's value added to by society and the state. This is where the distinction is. Most people think their "house" is worth $2MM - no it's the land, the wood and bricks are easily replaced.
- HeyLaughingBoy 11y agoDepends on where you live. My house is worth far more than the land it sits on. I know people who've bought a couple acres for under $25k just so they can put a mobile home or an RV on it.