3 ms·
The article is somewhat difficult to read. I think "segregation" should be "zoning" throughout most of the article? I get that he's trying to draw a parallel
by paulddraper 11y ago
The article is somewhat difficult to read.
I think "segregation" should be "zoning" throughout most of the article?
I get that he's trying to draw a parallel to the historical practice of separating public facilities by race, but the connection is tenuous. One is de jure separation by ancestry for public, tax-funded, government facilities. The other is de facto separation by finances for private property (enabled by legal architectural requirements).
In any case, following this logic implies overturning most zoning restrictions and HOAs. (I myself am currently uncertain on my opinion on this.)
- jannotti 11y agoHis point is precisely that segregation laws and zoning laws do the same thing, so he's trying to use language that makes that obvious. It's not a leap really, right? To "segregate" things is almost synonymous with putting things into their proper "zones" isn't it?
- vmorgulis 11y agoHe is right it's the same thing with different intents.
- paulddraper 11y agoYes, and I eventually got that. segregate, zone, partition, divide, separate, categorize have similar English definitions. This is just my impression, but "We must repeal our zoning laws" would have been an easier thesis to follow then "We must repeal our segregation laws", particularly since they work differently.