8 ms·
Ok, I laughed out loud on that one. This quote in particular, "The vehicle and the test driver 'believed the bus would slow or allow the Google (autonomous vehi
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Ok, I laughed out loud on that one. This quote in particular, "The vehicle and the test driver 'believed the bus would slow or allow the Google (autonomous vehicle) to continue.'"
Bus drivers in the Bay Area are notorious for ignoring traffic (and pedestrians). Apparently there is some indemnity or statutes that make suing either the transportation agency or the driver nearly impossible and so pretty quickly people learn that the bus drivers drive with impunity. Plenty of stories posted to the local traffic column in the paper, and shared amongst neighbors and in the department of safety's "blotter" feature.
Google needs to go back and program their cars to always assume that buses are out to get them and avoid them at all cost, They are an active traffic hazard often operated by a disinterested and distracted driver. The only way to "win" is to not be where ever the bus is.
- drchiu 11y agoAgreed. Google needs to increase the settings on "Defensive Driving". Just because the Google robot drives in a reasonable manner doesn't mean the humans around it will.
- theklub 11y agoMade me think, someone can wave you ahead, etc. There won't be that option with a robot unless they install a indicator.
- technofiend 11y agoUp next: Google self-driving buses, finally American buses run with the same attention to time tables that Swiss ones do. And added benefit: they obey traffic safety laws.
- simplemath 11y agoAny job that chiefly involves a human operating a vehicle will not exist for much longer.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoNot really: https://medium.com/@scobleizer/don-t-worry-uber-lyft-drivers-self-driving-cars-won-t-take-your-job-for-at-least-a-decade-3b8c58a7f102#.45ft79ln0 https://medium.com/@scobleizer/don-t-worry-uber-lyft-drivers...
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoMaaybe for the "easy" stuff like public transport. But for many of the specialised jobs that also boil down to a human operating a vehicle, e.g. excavators, log cutting machines, snowplows etc. it takes a human who already knows how to drive a car many months, even years to learn how to do it. Since the market for these machines is many orders of magnitude smaller than for cars, and each machine type is so specialised that there is limited overlap, so the cost-benefit ratio is much worse than for cars. Thus I think it will take a lot longer for these jobs to be automated away.
- simplemath 11y agoHeavy Machine Operators are probably good for 5 or 10 years longer than the rest... tops. Isn't Rio Tinto already using AI to operate its haulers? Even in niche specialized corners, the value prop of self operating machines is going to become increasingly overwhelming.
- throwaway2048 11y ago
- jerf 11y ago"always assume that buses are out to get them and avoid them at all cost" This is a case where perhaps the computers have too much imagination. We actually tell human drivers to drive that way, but as humans we all know that we don't really mean that we need to worry about someone driving in front of us suddenly slamming their brakes, drifting 180 degrees, and driving at us full speed. Tell a computer to assume too much malice and the car will refuse to even move, because it's pretty easy to specify the search algorithm that will find that outcome. We have to specify the exact level of malice the computer can reasonably expect, which is way harder. And it will still, by necessity, at times be an underestimate.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoYou make an excellent point, however as I've been recently up to my hips in RNNs I wonder if we can figure out how to score encounters, can the car learn the level of malice to expect, can it learn it to the level of perhaps the individual driver shifts? My daughter took the 54 to DeAnza community college and learned which drivers were ok, which were mean, and which were indifferent. Would regular exposure of the car to the bus at different times of day allow it to figure that out? Can we start with an expected level of malice and tune it? Fun question to think about.
- thoughtpalette 11y agoAlso agree. Drivers operate the same, unsafely, in Chicago as well.
- mring33621 11y agoYeah, in Chicago, it's very clear that the onus is on the non-bus vehicle to avoid a potential accident. Which pretty much sums up the main tenet of defensive driving...
- gardano 11y agoFrom my memories of driving in Boston, defensive drivers were an absolute menace. If you don't drive aggressively, you're the cause of problems… Perhaps each autonomous car needs to have a cultural knowledge, based on location.
- BrandonY 11y agoI drive defensively and lived in Boston. I couldn't deal with the mindset of Boston drivers. I moved to Seattle. I am so much happier here. Sometimes drivers cause traffic jams because they spend too much time waving at each other to go out of turn: "You go!" "No, you go!" "No, I insist, you definitely stopped before me!" These are my people.
- gardano 11y agoand you're the reason I spent too much time on the Mass Pike ;) There's no such thing as merge, there is only shove! Edit: No blame devolves to you. As I said, it's a cultural thing.
- lamontcg 11y agoI seriously need to move from Seattle to Boston. I can't stand the drivers here who completely vapor-lock at 4-ways until someone waves them through... Of course I don't really like 4 ways in SF where you have to fight tooth and nail for your right of way, but some happy medium where everyone just efficiently goes when its their turn would be nice...
- RIMR 11y agoI just moved to Seattle proper and stopped driving altogether. Too stressful, no matter where you live.
- fucking_tragedy 11y agoThis is why I hate driving in those types of areas. A good percentage of the time two people end up trying to enter the intersection at once because hand signals are not a clear communication method for signaling right of way.
- mb_72 11y agoThis made me think - and excuse my ignorance if this is a known and solved problem already - that for autonomous driver software there needs to be some significant degree of customisation allowable for local conditions, where 'local' seems to need to be 'in a local area, like the Bay Area' for example, not just country-wide right-of-way and correct side of road rules. Here in South Australia public transport buses are extended unofficial better right of way standing (when departing from the curb), for example. There are also new laws determining the required minimum passing distance between a cyclist and a car to be 1m if travelling 60km/hr or less, and 1.5m if travelling > 60km/hr; and car drivers are allowed to cross double-white lines to avoid cyclists. It seems to me there are ample opportunity for 'edge case' bugs to occur in the autonomous vehicle software when local conditions are taken into account, and an untested set of requirements are applied specific to a country / city / district.
- cloverich 11y agoA somewhat ironic thought experiment: If a reasonably practical early implementation of Google cars would be to replace municipal bus (drivers)... isn't it in the bus driver's self interest to try and get Google cars to hit them (and potentially keep them off the road.)
- mabbo 11y agoIn Ontario at least (and maybe other places) it's actually law that you always yield to the bus. Well, maybe the laws actually aren't as strong as that, but the bus drivers know there are some laws that say they have more rights, and the rest of us kind of fall in line. I mean, he's driving a bus and he thinks he has the right of way. This effectively means he has the right of way.
- diogenescynic 11y ago>so pretty quickly people learn that the bus drivers drive with impunity. So true. There are no worse drivers on the roads than MUNI bus drivers. They are terrifying to drive near. I've nearly been crushed by MUNI buses multiple times, while driving in my own lane minding traffic laws.
- DrScump 11y agoThis is VTA (formerly Santa Clara County Transit), not Muni. Regardless, both (and A/C Transit and BART) have extremely strong unions.