3 ms·
>> What they claim to be doing is totally reasonable, and pretty much every IoT device works like this. There's simply no good way to get out-of-the-home commun
by phkahler 11y ago
>> What they claim to be doing is totally reasonable, and pretty much every IoT device works like this. There's simply no good way to get out-of-the-home communication to work reliably without having the device connect to the cloud.
None of these devices need out-of-the-home communication for the users benefit. Not even Nest.
- zaroth 11y agoTo change the temp on my Nest when I'm away from home there are 4 options I can see; - central control via the manufacturer (thermostat talks to nest server, my app talks to nest server) - dyndns with NAT hole punching or upnp (a way for my app to know what IP the nest is listening on and connect directly to it - a vpn from my phone to my home and the app discovers the nest as a local network device. You still need a way to make the VPN connection to your router, bringing us back to dyndns or some way to discover your IP or hope it is static - a P2P overlay network, such as what Krebs is complaining about, or more securely, a Tor hidden service.