3 ms·
It's still not disproportionate. Old people don't get more votes. They actually vote. Just because there happen to be more old people, and they tend to vote mo
by pc86 11y ago
It's still not disproportionate. Old people don't get more votes. They actually vote.
Just because there happen to be more old people, and they tend to vote more conservatively, does not mean that it's "disproportionate" when they actually vote and influence policy. If all the baby boomers died tomorrow nobody would bemoan the disproportionate influence of 40-year olds in the next election.
- coldtea 11y ago>It's still not disproportionate. Old people don't get more votes. I'm afraid you have misread disproportionate to mean some kind of unfair representation. It just means "they are more, and thus get more votes", i.e. that their influence (because of their numbers) is higher. Nobody implied they get more than 1 vote per person... disproportionate: "too large or too small in comparison with something else"
- pc86 11y agoBut their representation is not too large. It's exactly the size it should be - one vote for one person. "Too" means excessively. Boomer representation is only "too large" if you happen to disagree with their policy choices (which I usually do) - but it's not an unfair level of representation or influence, which is what disproportionate does mean in this context.
- coldtea 11y ago>But their representation is not too large. It's exactly the size it should be - one vote for one person. Consider a country with 10,100 people, where 100 baby boomers voted and only 1 younger person bothered to vote but the general demographics are the inverse ratio (10,000 young people, 100 baby boomers). The exact word to use for the baby boomers voting influence there would be "disproportionate". That's literally what the word means -- it's not tied to the voting system, or stealing votes. It's disproportionate not because they got more votes than it's fair to according to the voting system, or because they don't deserve those votes, but because they got more votes than what would be the ideal proportional representation of the two demographic groups. (E.g. where young/old is as close to votes_of_young/votes_of_old as a ratio). The two groups have the same capacity/opportunity to get proportional representation (in the voting system), but they don't have actual proportional representation (in the voting results).
- cunac 11y agoand that is a reason to blame "old" people for what exactly? Because young are lazy to vote ? Only if you go by extension that I intentionally raised my kids to not to vote as a part of my evil plan for dominance over young. sheesh
- coldtea 11y ago>and that is a reason to blame "old" people for what exactly? Because young are lazy to vote ? Who said that that, in itself, is reason to blame anybody? It's just an empirical, quantifiable, observation. That said, there are many OTHER, valid, reasons to blame "old" people, or the baby boomer generation, and lots of them have been laid out in the comment section. >Only if you go by extension that I intentionally raised my kids to not to vote as a part of my evil plan for dominance over young. sheesh Well, I don't think anybody brought this conspiracy shit up, or even implied it. Just that: a) older people are over-representent at elections, b) thus they exert the most political influence c) most politicians elected are crap d) that these get elected is predominantly the fault of older people One might argue that younger people are also to blame for not participating as much in elections, but that's probably not as bad as actively voting for and supporting crap.
- Scarblac 11y ago"They are more, and thus get more votes" that is _proportional_ voting. x% of the people have x% of the vote. Disproportionate means they get _more_ than you would already expect from proportional representation.
- coldtea 11y agoNope, it also means that they have much more votes in comparison to young voters. It's not about cheating or "proportional representation". It could mean that too, if we were discussing voting systems, but we are not. We're discussing the fair share of the vote each group gets -- and how the total of young votes vs old votes are out of proportion, that is imbalanced. disproportionate: "too large or too small in comparison with something else" (dictionary)