4 ms·
Wrong. It's only "disproportionate" because that cohort actually votes. The only reason that group has more power than any other group is that 20-29 year olds d
by pc86 11y ago
Wrong. It's only "disproportionate" because that cohort actually votes. The only reason that group has more power than any other group is that 20-29 year olds don't vote. People in their 60's do.
- Ambroos 11y agoWe notice the same thing in Belgium however, where voting is mandatory. Younger generations tend to vote for far more progressive parties, while the older generations stick with conservative parties.
- pc86 11y agoI was arguing against the use of the word "disproportionate" which implies unfair. I don't think it's at all strange that younger people tend to be more progressive, regardless of party.
- coldtea 11y ago>Wrong. It's only "disproportionate" because that cohort actually votes. The only reason that group has more power than any other group is that 20-29 year olds don't vote. People in their 60's do. Wrong too, I'm afraid. In lots of Western countries the average age of the population has rose as high as 40 year old (in contrast with older values of even less than 30). So it's not always that 'young people don't vote', it's also there are less of them too.
- pc86 11y agoIt's still not disproportionate. Old people don't get more votes. They actually vote. Just because there happen to be more old people, and they tend to vote more conservatively, does not mean that it's "disproportionate" when they actually vote and influence policy. If all the baby boomers died tomorrow nobody would bemoan the disproportionate influence of 40-year olds in the next election.
- coldtea 11y ago>It's still not disproportionate. Old people don't get more votes. I'm afraid you have misread disproportionate to mean some kind of unfair representation. It just means "they are more, and thus get more votes", i.e. that their influence (because of their numbers) is higher. Nobody implied they get more than 1 vote per person... disproportionate: "too large or too small in comparison with something else"
- pc86 11y agoBut their representation is not too large. It's exactly the size it should be - one vote for one person. "Too" means excessively. Boomer representation is only "too large" if you happen to disagree with their policy choices (which I usually do) - but it's not an unfair level of representation or influence, which is what disproportionate does mean in this context.
- coldtea 11y ago>But their representation is not too large. It's exactly the size it should be - one vote for one person. Consider a country with 10,100 people, where 100 baby boomers voted and only 1 younger person bothered to vote but the general demographics are the inverse ratio (10,000 young people, 100 baby boomers). The exact word to use for the baby boomers voting influence there would be "disproportionate". That's literally what the word means -- it's not tied to the voting system, or stealing votes. It's disproportionate not because they got more votes than it's fair to according to the voting system, or because they don't deserve those votes, but because they got more votes than what would be the ideal proportional representation of the two demographic groups. (E.g. where young/old is as close to votes_of_young/votes_of_old as a ratio). The two groups have the same capacity/opportunity to get proportional representation (in the voting system), but they don't have actual proportional representation (in the voting results).
- cunac 11y agoand that is a reason to blame "old" people for what exactly? Because young are lazy to vote ? Only if you go by extension that I intentionally raised my kids to not to vote as a part of my evil plan for dominance over young. sheesh
- roymurdock 11y agoVoting is only a small part of the power equation. Money and influence is a much larger one. Captains of business, finance, and education make a lot of important decisions and use money to influence the political process through lobbying and litigation. As corporations grow in power, gaining more rights and representation, so does this channel of political influence, which is controlled almost exclusively by an older cohort. The article calls this out in detail: casino interests played a huge role in destroying Sydney's nightlife in order to funnel drinkers to the casino bars that were exempt from shutdown laws. Notable exceptions would be Mark Zuckerberg, Jack Dorsey, Evan Spiegel. But they are just that: exceptions. And I wouldn't exactly consider any of them role models or champions for a younger generation.
- tunichtgut 11y agoDont forget the power of the media! Newspapers, internet websites, public TV and radio stations. The they tell the "truth". The truth of the baby boomers.
- CM30 11y agoI'm not sure the problem with the media is an age thing as much as a wealth thing. Wages for journalists are at rock bottom at the moment, and media publications are losing a fairly large amount of money due to the increased use of adblockers and competition from free internet sites. So the only people who can afford to become part of the established 'media' are the already well off types. So the people who'd argue for change can't afford to live on the wages provided, leaving only the people with a decent amount of money in the bank (and who usually trend towards having more conservative or authoritarian views). It might also be why journalism isn't particularly diverse in terms of who works in the field (despite what some of them like arguing about), because non minority candidates tend to have the support networks to fall back on to continue working in the field. If there's a predominance of older people at the higher levels in the media world on the other hand, I suspect it's because getting rich in this industry was a lot easier before the internet was a big thing. Most of these people started when anyone wanting visibility had to go through the old media gatekeepers...
- branchless 11y agoThey are voting to enslave the young via debt. Democracy isn't supposed to be mob rule.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoCuriously I read a Bernie piece that condemns Baby Boomers for wanting a Balanced Budget. Apparently that is a swear word now? So which is it - drowning in debt, or starved by a balanced budget.
- branchless 11y agoIt's land value tax which will pull the false gains from the boomers and give value to the labour of the young again. I'm not really very interested in Sanders except that he is clearly a response by a frustrated youth.
- pc86 11y agoThis line of reasoning is barely even worth a response.
- bryondowd 11y agoI haven't checked on this, but I would wager that a rather disproportionate number of 20-29 year olds would find it much more difficult to vote than people in their 60s. Sure, it's probably possible to register in advance and get a mail-in ballot, but that is rarely done and I expect there's some hoops to jump through there. As far as actually going to the polls, young folk tend to work jobs that make that very difficult, if not quite impossible. If you are living paycheck to paycheck, and your job doesn't afford you paid days off, and you're scheduled to work that day, then you're just going to work and not vote. Anything else would set you back in a way that would be more immediately damaging than not getting your vote. And even if you could afford to take an unpaid day off, in spite of it being illegal to prevent someone from taking time off to vote, I expect it would put most people in the bad graces of their employers to exercise that right. And it's hard to prove that your rights have been violated when you get fired for being 'unreliable' or just get scheduled for fewer hours the next several weeks because 'that's just how the schedule worked out'. These employers aren't trying to disenfranchise the young, they're just acting in their own best interests by maintaining control and keeping people working, and the current job market gives them far too much leverage. And that's not even getting into people with kids. Compare this to 60+, who are probably often retired or semi-retired, or working a job at a higher level where they've earned some form of paid time off, or are financially stable enough to just take the day off without pay, etc. They have no kids at home to take care of. They can much more easily just head over to the polls that day, without having to make extensive arrangements in advance. *And no, this isn't universal, just general trends. Yes, some young folk have professional positions with paid time off, some don't work. Likewise, some older folk are stuck working crappy low end jobs to make ends meet. But when we're talking percentages, I'm rather confident that the older generation is more likely to be able to go out and vote on one particular day in November.