3 ms·
How can measuring something verify that it was deliberately built too low? As opposed to built too low out of ignorance, incompetence, by accident, or for some
by chrisseaton 11y ago
How can measuring something verify that it was deliberately built too low? As opposed to built too low out of ignorance, incompetence, by accident, or for some good reason that you aren't aware of but unrelated to the politics you think it is?
- Spooky23 11y agoIn the case of Robert Moses, he pointed out his disdain for blacks and Puerto Ricans in public on a regular basis. Robert Caro wrote an epic biography of the man with intense details of how he ticked.
- chrisseaton 11y agoYou can measure something and determine that it's probably too low. And you can look at someone's public statements and determine that it's probably deliberate. But you can't determine someone's intentions with a tape measure.
- Spooky23 11y agoI'd suggest reading the Caro book. The author literally spent decades studying the man and traced the arc of his life from his teenage years to political boss. It's pretty clear that the man was a racist, and personally drove publics works projects to keep races he disliked away from public parks, beaches and other things.
- chrisseaton 11y agoI don't think you understand my point because whether or not the man was clearly racist isn't relevant to it. The original quote was > measured the overpasses on the Wantagh Parkway himself to verify that they were in fact deliberately built too low I'm questioning how the measurement of the bridge allows it to be determined if the bridge is deliberately, or accidentally too low, in the absence of other information. You're suggesting that there is copious other evidence that the bridge was deliberately too low, but that kind of proves my point. The measurement didn't show that it was deliberate - other evidence did instead. But this is becoming a bit of a ridiculous conversation for such a trivial point. I was just pointing out that it was sloppy writing.
- manicdee 11y agoYou have a statement of claim from the guy who built the bridge. You then go and measure the bridge to verify the statements made by the person who built the bridge. Read the book :D
- chrisseaton 11y agoBut what you're saying agrees with me :) The measuring doesn't verify the 'deliberate' claim, does it? It's only verifies the too low part. So > measured the overpasses on the Wantagh Parkway himself to verify that they were in fact deliberately built too low is nonsense. He measured the overpass to verify that it was too low. And he used statements from the person to verify the deliberate part. The measurement by itself doesn't prove the intent.