9 ms·
How Moving Is Linked to Losing Friends
- hkmurakami 11y agoFor this reason, I tell college applicants that there's value to going to a school in the economic area you expect to work in (straightforward if it's LA, SV, or NY). Most of your friends are going to stay in that area. I lost most of my college friends when I moved back to the west coast.
- quanticle 11y agoIs that actually a good idea, though? Schools in California and New York tend to be quite expensive. Moreover, it's arguably much safer for people, to move after college, when they have more maturity and an improved economic outlook than it is for them to move far away from home just after leaving high school. If a high-schooler gets into trouble in college, it's much better for them if their college is a couple of hundred miles from their parents and their existing social network, as opposed to being a couple of thousand miles away. It's much easier for kids who are marginal to get that extra support and attention, which can mean the difference between dropping out and graduating. Certainly, in my case, I'm very glad that I chose to move away after college, rather than before. I had a hard time in university, and the extra support I got from my parents was crucial in getting me out with a diploma. I would not have had that support if I'd moved to California or New York for my computer science degree.
- yardie 11y agoI'm not so sure. I went to uni in a different state, 1000 miles from home. I was also one of those marginal students (low income, poor schools, poor neighborhood, single parent, etc). Freshman year, moving to a new state made me a bit monastic. While my new friends, who were in state, were going home, constantly hanging out with friends from high school I would spend my weekends studying, try new interesting activities, listen to music, etc. Being so far from family just made me more self-reliant and resourceful. Example, my roommate would take a car load of laundry home every month because he didn't know how to wash his clothes and could not be bothered to figure it out. While being self reliant prepared me for life it did not help with the studies. It took me a few years and a few failed courses before I really learned how to study. Not at the grade school level but at the university level. But that was not because of the distance to the school. Being first in my family I had no one to lean on. Now my siblings are doing much better because I was the first, took all the arrows to the chest and mentored them over the stumbling blocks I encountered when transitioning to university.
- ska 11y agoIt is sort of the opposite with post-graduate schooling. Almost everyone you meet is from somewhere else, and going somewhere else in the next 5 years.
- rl3 11y agoThe majority of people can ultimately attribute meeting nearly all of their friends to either work or school. Having friends also makes meeting new friends both easier and far more likely. People who move around often are hit pretty hard by that dynamic. I'd say people with little to no educational background who then work remote or otherwise solitary jobs also have it rough in that regard.
- madaxe_again 11y agoYeah... it also has a profound effect on children. I grew up around the world backwards - my dad was a futures trader, and would end up working on a different exchange in a different corner of the planet every 18-24 months. He was also a serial philanderer, which it turns out was the actual reason for the frequent employment changes, but hey. Between being born and leaving school at 18, I lived in four continents, a dozen countries, twenty houses/homes, and had attended nine schools - only in my last five years of education did I stay put - up until that point I'd not spent more than two years at any school. So what effect does this have? I have a weird approach to relationships with other humans. Being dislocated frequently has lead to a low investment high yield model of human interaction - that is to say, I spend as little time and effort as possible on relationships with others, and have an understanding of which levers can be pulled for maximal attachment (on their behalf, not mine - I stay unattached as losing people over and over and over gets a bit painful) with minimal effort. This mostly comprises moulding my external interactions with others according to the expectations that I perceive from them, and thus aiming for the "I met the most amazing X" the other night zone. This isn't because I want people to think highly of me or because I want to take advantage of people - rather because I want friendship in a lonely world but don't want to invest time and emotion into a relationship that may just be whipped away from me. Selfish, I know, but I have to survive somehow. I don't stay in touch with people I don't see frequently, to the extent that people who were my best friends 10, 15, 20 years ago (all different people of course) I haven't spoken to in 10, 15 or 20 years. They may as well have never existed. In short, it's turned me borderline psychopathic in terms of how I interact with others, I've learned to be a loner, I can get on with anyone, I can reduce anyone to quivering rage. I don't think humans were really built to lose their entire social group every eighteen months - it's not aligned with the whole primate hierarchy thing. I recognise the same thing in others who have had similar backgrounds, and almost as oddly they notice the same in me. It usually leads to us simply ignoring each other on mutual understanding of the pointlessness of getting to know one another.
- jheriko 11y agoi'm not sure this is exactly a revelation. did i miss something?
- xuhu 11y agoIt was pretty bleak except maybe the last paragraph. "Perhaps this occasional tendency to keep friendships from getting too deep, and being willing to let them go [...] comes from the knowledge of how hard it is to leave people."
- jzwinck 11y agoA related effect happens after you move. In your first months in a new place you can easily seem interesting and get invited to parties and whatnot because you're new in town. But you're like an animal in a zoo: look at him, so unusual, oh let's move on to the next one. The people you meet will usually be longtime residents of your new home. They have evidence that your friendship will not last, because after all you just told them all about the place you left behind. You'll probably leave this place behind someday, so becoming deeply involved with you is likely a big waste of time. Don't worry, there's an expat meet-up every Wednesday! We have no idea who will be there, but maybe you can meet some new people!
- Paul_S 11y agoWhen you move you change acquaintances, you don't lose friends unless you already wanted to lose touch with them. I know it sounds like a no true Scotsman but with cheap airlines, skype, online gaming etc. it's pretty easy to keep in touch if you actually want to.
- wallacoloo 11y agoWhat about my rock-climbing partner, and my musician friends (some of the stuff we do can be done over the 'net, but we can't jam remotely)? I guess these all fall under the category of "take a plane"? It certainly contradicts the spur-of-the-moment environment facilitated by cellphones though, whereby we tend to make plans just a few hours before meeting up. Keeping in touch is definitely possible, but those types of friendships would become nearly unrecognizable if we're separated by a plane flight.
- yason 11y agoIf a friendship revolves around being able to do some similar thing together, it's probably not a friendship. In a friendship it's about the other person and it doesn't matter if you can't climb/surf/jam together because it's not about doing. People I hang out with because of a hobby are pals, peers, even acquaintances. A friend is a couple of steps above that: a friend I would see outside the usual circumstances. I go have lunch with my colleagues but it's only one or two I actually meet outside of work, and those are potential friend material. Test of true friendship is when you don't have any other other excuse to meet except yourselves, and you still meet.
- wallacoloo 11y agoThis seems highly subjective to me, and to be honest, I can't help but be mildly offended - you just discredited the vast majority of my friendships, and yet I don't even understand what you're trying to get at. I don't connect with people via words. I've always felt people are primarily defined by their actions, so it is very much about the "doing" for me, and it's through doing things together that I make connections with others. Obviously, my friend with whom I rock climb isn't just my rock-climbing partner - we do other things as well, many of which are unplanned and are new experiences. But it's the possibility of playing out our spur-of-the-moment ideas, as well as the other regular hobbies, that make our friendship even remotely interesting. Without being able to do those things together (which is way, way more difficult when you have to take a plane ride to visit), neither of us would be able to glean any meaning from the other's existence. I don't know - was I really far off in how I interpreted your comment? What is a friendship, to you?
- quanticle 11y agoLewin thought that this idea of friends as fast fashion—easily acquired, emotionlessly discarded when worn out—might be spurred by the United States’s high level of residential mobility. American society was mobile in his day and has only gotten more mobile since. How does the author square this with all of the recent studies that show that American residential mobility is at an all-time low? [1] And yet it doesn't seem that the average American is making more deep friendships, even though he or she is staying for longer in a single metropolitan area. [1]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/05/11/why-arent-americans-moving-anymore-heres-a-new-theory/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/05/11/why-a...
- aksquestions 11y agoOver the same time period, the US population has been increasing in diversity. Among other negative aspects, increased diversity increases social alienation. It reduces social cohesion and trust not just between groups but within them. [.] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_D._Putnam#Diversity_and_trust_within_communities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_D._Putnam#Diversity_and... [#] http://politicalscience.ku.dk/staff/Academic_staff/?pure=files%2F130251172%2FDinesen_S_nderskov_Ethnic_Diversity_and_Social_Trust_Forthcoming_ASR.pdf http://politicalscience.ku.dk/staff/Academic_staff/?pure=fil...
- chei0aiV 11y agoI blame the Internet.
- hoodoof 11y agoThe older I get the more I value the small number of real friends I have.
- brightball 11y agoA lot of that is how we create friendships. Growing up in an area, you have many years with the same people. In college, you have many years with the same people. After you graduate, even if you're in the same area there will be multiple phases to friendship. 1. You're going to be working and single/married but still have plenty of time to spend after hours and on weekends with friends. The crux comes from income disparities that might prevent some friends from spending money on activities that others are willing to do. 2. As soon as kids happen, the group dynamics shift. The parents are often times going to be exhausted for a few years (especially if both are working), going out requires hiring a babysitter, inviting people over involves working around the kids or trying to avoid waking them. We host our friends all the time just because it's easier, but it's very different. Overtime this shift in dynamics becomes a big deal. 3. The solution for getting together with friends when you have small kids is other people with kids the same age who can play together. This causes another significant shift in the dynamic as you start to create new friends with parents from your neighborhood, school, church, scouts, etc. If you're in an new area and many people in these groups already know each other, then you're going to be responsible for making the effort to get to know them.
- pc86 11y ago> If you're in an new area and many people in these groups already know each other, then you're going to be responsible for making the effort to get to know them. I never understood this mindset. From a sheer work perspective, it's easier for ten people in an established group to make a small effort to the new person than it is for that new person to make the same (or even less) effort toward all ten. And from a psychological perspective, they're already in an unfamiliar environment and likely without any friends or family. It's much more humane for the established folks to reach out to the new people.
- brightball 11y agoWell, there's a little more to it than that. First off, there's the diffusion of responsibility. The more people there are that can make an invite, the more people assume somebody else would do it. Then there's the group dynamic factor. If anybody in the group has any issue with you, other people can feel awkward about inviting you. The last is the benefit factor. The benefit of getting more ingrained to the community for somebody who isn't established is for the person who isn't established. The people already ingrained have their routine, so their incentive to keep making overtures isn't nearly as strong as your desire for those overtures.
- a2tech 11y agoI'm not shocked. Its callous but I'm open with my friends that when they move, we're not really going to be friends any more. I don't see you any more, we don't chat all the time because you're in a different time zone, you have a lot of things to do. Why pretend that we're still friends? Its just a lot of hassle for everyone.
- p4wnc6 11y agoI think this has more to do with the way you consume friendship than with the idea in general. For me personally, even if I live in the same town as my best friend, I will barely see him. Most communication that deeply matters to me happens through text messages or email, not through in-person interaction. I also tend to have a very small number of people that I consider friends, but I am fiercely loyal and protective of that small set of people. I don't want a large network of friends because my experience in life is that very few people are able or willing to help me and very few people share the perspectives that I have. For the few that make good friends, geographical distance is one of the last things I would expect to affect the friendship.
- artmageddon 11y ago> Why pretend that we're still friends? Its just a lot of hassle for everyone. I've always felt that friendships shouldn't be based on physical proximity, and in my opinion it's not really fair or prudent to other people(or yourself, for that matter) to boil a relationship down to a binary yes/no. Personal example: I live in NJ, and a college friend of mine moved to FL shortly after we both graduated together in 2004. His(and his wife's) kid just turned one year old, and while we don't talk every day, we still keep in good contact throughout the week despite both of our crazy busy schedules. Contrast that to another someone else I've known since 8th grade: we went to middle/high school and part of college together, and continued to be great friends for a number of years post-university. However, we barely talk or hang out anymore, maybe once every few months, and it's pretty clear that we've drifted apart, despite living only maybe 10-20 minutes away from each other. I admit that I don't really put much effort into my friendship with him, as I'm sure he feels the same as well, but I wouldn't say either of us are bitter about it. I guess what I'm trying to say is just because someone isn't right there in driving distance doesn't mean they aren't there for you.
- baron816 11y agoReading these comments makes me feel really good about what I'm trying to do with my startup, Krewe (https://www.gokrewe.com https://www.gokrewe.com). It helps people make lasting, meaningful friendships that they can actually see and do stuff with everyday. It places people into a small social group where everyone lives within a half mile radius, and then encourages them to stick together and meet up often. There really is no reason why we all shouldn't have a close group of friends in our neighborhood, no matter how old we are, we just need an organization to help make those introductions and connections.
- nathan_f77 11y agoJust from reading your description, this sounds awesome! I thought about building something very similar. Especially as someone who has moved around quite a bit, it can be hard to make friends in new places. Hey also your site seems to be down at: https://gokrewe.com/ https://gokrewe.com/ It looks like it only works if you add the www. in front
- baron816 11y agoOh thanks for the heads up on that. And that's for the words of support.
- Grishnakh 11y agoHow well does it facilitate discrimination? For instance, in the small town I'm stuck in at the moment, most people are probably religious, and I definitely don't want to become friends with any of them. So a service that lets you find people living near you to be friends with would need to allow me to discriminate against people like that easily, or I'm not going to bother using it.
- baron816 11y agoI think that would be a little too controversial for me to try to start out with.
- 11y ago
- fennecfoxen 11y ago> American society was mobile in his day and has only gotten more mobile since. This is the conventional wisdom. Is it true? I've seen assertions challenging it in the past, suggesting Americans were less likely to make big moves today than in the past, and instead remain in the same city (this was in connection with some divorce/custody cases). Blurbs challenging the assertion: http://www.newsmax.com/US/americans-moving-less-than/2014/05/28/id/573682/ http://www.newsmax.com/US/americans-moving-less-than/2014/05... https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/post/why-are-americans-moving-less-perhaps-they-dont-need-to/2012/05/18/gIQAi0L3YU_blog.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/post/why-are-a... http://uselectionatlas.org/FORUM/index.php?topic=151554.0;wap2 http://uselectionatlas.org/FORUM/index.php?topic=151554.0;wa... and one on how Americans are still mobile compared to the rest of the world: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/05/15/the-united-states-is-still-one-of-the-most-mobile-countries-in-the-world/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/05/15/the-u...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- epimetheus 11y agoI pretty much only had a handful of friends before I moved 2000+ miles away, but honestly, the one and only one that I still talk to was the only one that was really my friend. The rest were more close acquaintances, past roommates, etc. Some are still on the 'real' friend list, but have lives that kept us from hanging out, even when there wasn't distance. Business, etc. After moving my wife and I have picked up some couple 'friends,' but they are more playdate type (kids near same age), and party type acquaintances. I don't meet up with either of them individually (and they are socialites, so are always doing stuff with groups of people, I don't know that they have any friends that they just hang out together with, other than in a group). My closest friend still hangs out with us once a year. We chat and email weekly if not daily, and we both fly to each other's cities to visit, or we meet somewhere and hang out, vacation-like.
- venomsnake 11y agoI guess different cultures have different ideas of friendship. For me a friend is someone you call at 3AM with "I need you", and he don't even asks the question - "who is this guy", while you bury the body. And some for whom you will do the same. You may have a couple of those in your life if you are extremely lucky and you don't lose them even if they are half the world away and you talk once per year. But I guess the majority of friendships the articles talk about are acquaintances. A true friendship is forged in fire, hardened, tempered and not brittle at all.
- TheOneTrueKyle 11y agoI've experienced an almost opposite situation a few years ago. Rather than moving away and losing friends, life brought me to a location in which I couldn't care less to live in. Because of this, I would make a great effort to not make friends, not socialize, and not have anything to do with the community. I lived with the assumption that it was a temporary situation and would be over soon. It wasn't as temporary as I had hoped...
- ska 11y agoFor what it is worth, I think that is a terrible approach in general. Life is what is happening to you now, not some vague future plan or wished for remembrance.
- TheOneTrueKyle 11y agoOh I completely agree that it isn't the best approach and I agree that life is happening in the moment. However, living in the moment when you are in a terrible situation is rough. In the moment, depression and suicide seem like a good idea, but that is probably not a good move (not that this is a problem for me). But living in the immediate moment certainly will help any depression of what could be. Enjoying the smell of your environment or taking in nature certainly prevent you from thinking of your terrible living situation.
- Grishnakh 11y agoI'm in much the same situation now. Don't listen to that other guy: if you're living in a place where you don't intend to stay, and the locals really aren't people you want to spend your time with, then don't. All the people around me are a bunch of small-town religious people, so I have no desire to get to know them, or else they're going to start asking me about my "personal relationship with Jesus" or somesuch. I'm just working on my finances and planning my move out of here, and for socializing I try to take a day every weekend and drive to the nearest big city and do something with a Meetup group there. I meet some very interesting people that way, unlike the people I currently live around.
- 11y ago
- davidw 11y agoGenerally, we've been really happy with our move from Italy to Bend, Oregon, but leaving our friends behind has been one of the most difficult aspects of it. I miss the social interactions with both friends and most people in general, in Italy. "Hi, how are you?" is a genuine question, and not asked if you don't expect an answer.
- humbleMouse 11y agoBeing born and raised in Minneapolis and still living here, I think about this dynamic every single day. I hate the cold weather here but I have a HUGE circle of friends and know tons of people in the city. I really want to move somewhere warmer but I dread loosing all my friends and family.
- alvern 11y agoAlso being born and raised in Minneapolis; leave and come back. Most of your friends will still be here. A huge amount of my college/20-something friendships live in Colorado. There is so much of the world to experience before a mortgage, kids, and a job tie you down to one place.
- Grishnakh 11y ago>I really want to move somewhere warmer but I dread loosing all my friends and family. It's not right to keep them enslaved or confined. Slavery and involuntary imprisonment are wrong. You need to set them loose.
- bhewes 11y agoI have spent my life moving from place to place. One thing I have learned is how to keep friends, because of the internet and cheap plane flights. If my friend lives in the U.S. it is basically the same place to me. This maybe an extension of the fields I work in as they are global and have been for awhile.