28 ms·
...most of these are good people, and many of them have accomplished more in their lives than many of the denigrating commenters ever will. While true, I'll st
by Groxx 17y ago
...most of these are good people, and many of them have accomplished more in their lives than many of the denigrating commenters ever will.
While true, I'll still be prejudiced against people that leave comments like (#14):
wtf is this bullshttttttttttt all about. can i get n plzzzzzzzzz
and I'll actively argue that many who spell and act this poorly in public are probably at least as much of a detriment to society as they are a boon. Most of those smart-but-not-tech-savvy people can at least communicate properly.
edit: the comment prejudice applies to bashers too. Poor behavior is poor behavior.
- madair 17y agoPrejudice (1) : preconceived judgment or opinion (2) : an adverse opinion or leaning formed without just grounds or before sufficient knowledge Yep, sounds like you are prejudiced.
- Groxx 17y agoI did just admit it. Many of the worst-behavers I've encountered act similarly or worse on the internet, and the reverse has been quite accurate for the few I've encountered in that manner. It's certainly prejudice, but that doesn't make it wholly (or even mostly) invalid. Prejudices have a prejudiced opinion applied to them. That snarling dog? It may not bite you, but it's rational to be prejudiced towards believing it may harm you. Though it may often be wrong, it proves valuable in the long run. The same goes for the person with a knife out, glaring at you, looking drunk. It could be totally harmless, but it may not be. By all means, go into the dark alley with them if you are wholly against prejudice. Unless, of course, they're never examined. They can be wrong or detrimental just like anything else. But broken down, all rational behavior towards anything alive is effectively prejudice, because you can't have sufficient knowledge to predict it perfectly.
- madair 17y agoThere is nothing good about this at all, this is class warfare and culture warfare all wrapped up together, both very bad and both ripping America, among other places, apart right about....now. You have absolutely no clue about this person and yet you are prejudiced against him, her, it. Is he/she/it 10 years old? You have no clue. You don't know background, you know nothing except that this person just feels that they got cheated, and they are not experienced enough to know that they are simply on the wrong page. But hey, it's okay, because you admit it, huh?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- madair 17y agoKarma well spent. The doubled-consonants style is very popular with the 12-16 year old set right now. Congratulations on your prejudice.
- joeyo 17y agoYour prejudice is my Bayesian inference. In any rate, judging someone based on how they communicate is morally very different from judging them based on who they are. Communication is action, and if one cannot form opinions based on the actions of others, then indeed, what may we do? Passively observe the world go by?
- Groxx 17y agoYour prejudice is my Bayesian inference. +1 for a great quote xD
- madair 17y agoMy prejudice against prejudicial people? It's amazing how many people think that is a good argument. Typically prejudiced people. It a common enough movie-cliche too. I.e., gambler just lost the car saying, "Don't judge me, don't judge me!"
- Groxx 17y agoThe loss of all social filters is social anarchy. If you're an anarchist, then this likely appeals to you, but I'm not. We certainly have too many social filters, but having none enables malicious people to gain incredible power. Projections based on limited information are innate to not only humans, but learning in general. Sea cucumbers learn. This easily extends to projections of human behavior based on limited information, but some people view this as universally bad. Evidently, you are one of them. Enjoy your viewpoint.
- 17y ago
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Perceval 17y agoSome folks have put together a comment filter that flags any comments that are 'formally' stupid in the same way that #14 is: http://stupidfilter.org/main/ http://stupidfilter.org/main/
- Groxx 17y agoI really like the project's idea, but it's sadly pretty inaccurate from my tests (unless it's progressed significantly since I last saw it). Definitely worth a laugh, though :)
- epochwolf 17y agoI've found it seems to work fairly well until give it any text with formatting (markdown, bbcode, etc) at it. It seems to throw it's hands in the air and cry stupid.
- fhars 17y agoThas was a stupid comment :-). Of course the filter probably assumes that its input is text targeted at humans, not code targeted at a markup processor. Code is speech that is deliberately dumbed down so that is is in LALR or LL(n) or so, no wonder that a stupid-filter will trigger on that. Solution: remove the markup, then apply the filter on the content it is designed to analyse.
- epochwolf 17y agoAccording to the filter, it wasn't.
- sireat 17y agoMost clueless (but still good people, like the woman in the story above) didn't even leave a comment at all on RWW, probably just left the site completely baffled.
- lkozma 17y agoWhile I agree 99% with you, here's a story that happened to me: I was about the go to a summer school on computer science research and the organizers have set up a mailing list in advance. People generally wrote friendly introductory messages, but there was one guy who seemed totally incoherent. He was like: 'yo gouys, hope too c u soon, i wil com by trein, ll ariv at 7, rlly xcited'. I was about to send a reply and lecture him that writing in this way was disrespectful and annoying, but luckily I was too lazy to do it. When I eventually met him, it turned out that he was completely blind (since birth), managed to go through school in a really unfair school system (mostly with the help of a few good friends) and went to college to study computer science and he uses all sorts of inadequate tools to type and use the computer in general. Turned out he was an extremely intelligent person, able to visualize and solve differential equations in his head that I could not work out on paper, and in all fields he was very knowledgeable and articulate. I wish I could say that after this event I'm more careful in summarily judging people.