3 ms·
Surely a plane can be tied in a knot in R^3 (like a sheet of paper, a blanket) - and therefore trivially so in higher dimensions?
by OJFord 11y ago
Surely a plane can be tied in a knot in R^3 (like a sheet of paper, a blanket) - and therefore trivially so in higher dimensions?
- AgentME 11y agoA sheet of paper or a blanket would only be a plane segment.
- grandalf 11y agoA string is just a line segment
- Taniwha 11y agoI can imagine an infinitely long line with a know in the middle in 3d ... I guess the interesting question is "can you have an infinite plane with a knot in the middle in 5 dimensions?6 dimensions?"
- ustolemyname 11y agoYes, but the ends could be extended to infinity in arbitrary directions, so we can tie a knot in a line, not just a segment. You can't do that to the edges of a blanket knot (two sides run into the knot).
- baddox 11y agoA mathematical knot is like a loop of string. There are no ends. Of course, you could cut any mathematical knot wherever you like and make the two ends go to infinity if you'd like.
- ustolemyname 11y agoThank you, I appreciate the correct definition.
- OJFord 11y agoI understand a bit better after that, thanks. But a knot in a plane segment doesn't need to fold the ends in - I can grab a blanket in the middle, and tie a knot there, then extend edges infinitely still?
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoA knot is an embedding of S1 in R3, i.e. a closed loop and not a line segment.
- cynicalkane 11y agoAny such knot could be topologically deformed into a knot made of arbitrarily thin plane segment, which would end up being the same as a line knot. So knots made out of finite plane segments are uninteresting.
- OJFord 11y agoI should have been more clear though, I was imagining an infinite 'blanket', which I grab in the 'middle' (not an end) and tie a knot there. Or does that not count as (mathematical) knotting?
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoA sheet of paper or a blanket is equivalent to D2, the disc, which is not a plane.
- gohrt 11y agoFor it to be a mathematical "knot", the edges have to be sewn together into form a knotted sphere. The trivial way to knot a blanket doesn't yield a trivial way to connect all the edges without untying the knot.