4 ms·
If Apple arbitrarily removed Uber's app from their App Store: 1. Uber would file a lawsuit for a huge amount of damages. (They have enough money to be able to
by greenyoda 11y ago
If Apple arbitrarily removed Uber's app from their App Store:
1. Uber would file a lawsuit for a huge amount of damages. (They have enough money to be able to afford lots of lawyers.)
2. A large percentage of Apple's customers who are also Uber customers would be hugely pissed off and switch to Android phones.
3. There would be huge amounts of negative publicity. There would be congressional inquiries into anti-competitive behavior, and demands for government regulation. Apple's board might even fire the CEO.
It's almost inconceivable that Apple would do something so harmful to its own self-interest.
- milesskorpen 11y agoI don't understand (1). Why is Apple legally required to approve any app?
- raverbashing 11y ago- Abuse of dominant economic position - Having had a history of having the app on their store already So they better have a very good reason for taking their app out of the store
- greenyoda 11y agoThey're not legally required to approve any app. Banning Uber's app would not be cause for criminal action, but for a civil suit for damages or breach of contract. The argument might go something like this: 1. Uber's app had previously been approved. 2. Apple, by their previous policies, therefore led Uber to believe that they could build a business around an iOS app. Relying on that information, Uber invested billions of dollars into their business. 3. Apple, by now banning Uber's app, has committed an act that damages Uber. Also, it would be difficult for Apple to come up with criteria for an acceptable app that would disqualify Uber but not also millions of other apps, without having some new condition specifically aimed at Uber. This could be used as evidence that Apple intended to cause damage to Uber.
- Etheryte 11y agoThey could simply update their policy and then continue to remove it, which would make all the above points moot.
- lnanek2 11y ago> Also, it would be difficult for Apple to come up with criteria for an acceptable app that would disqualify Uber but not also millions of other apps, without having some new condition specifically aimed at Uber. Not really. Apple already has draconian terms to submit apps. They've done things like ban pretty wallpaper weather apps before and released their own version of it. They even attacked Flux and then duplicated the feature. It's perfectly legal since their terms basically say anything that competes with them is not allowed. So they could easily ban Uber and say you should be using their phone capability to call a cab.
- saganus 11y agoBut I think the point was that Uber also has a lot of money for lawyers so they could at least fight it and cause some stirr, media attention, etc, and then that in turn could damage Apple.
- greenyoda 11y ago"So they could easily ban Uber and say you should be using their phone capability to call a cab." - That argument would also apply to any other app that allowed you to order goods or services. - Apple doesn't offer phone service - they only sell phones. And they're certainly not in the taxi business. So I don't see how they could construct a convincing argument that Uber competes with them.
- karmacondon 11y agoDo you know of a previous case that's similar to what you're describing here? Because I'm having a hard time understand this. Unless Apple entered into an agreement with Uber, I don't see how Uber would have an expectation that their relationship with the App Store would continue in its same form into perpetuity. And I'm almost positive there is some condition in the apple developer agreement that says "We reserve the right to terminate without notice or reason" or something similar. What you're saying is reasonable, and I could see how a judge might agree with the arguments you've made. But it also seems like Apple could say, "We don't like the CEO of Uber's haircut", which is as valid as any other reason to terminate a non-contractual relationship. If Uber wanted protection for the billions they invested, they should have negotiated a proper agreement. Maybe I just don't understand how the law works.
- petra 11y ago>> congressional inquiries into anti-competitive behavior Anti-trust law requires having a monopoly(which Apple doesn't have) or acting together with other companies. So in this case it's probably legal. EDIT: that's basically the opinion of Keith Rabois, who litigated several anti-trust laws. https://www.quora.com/Why-was-Microsoft-punished-for-violating-antitrust-laws-while-Apple-which-is-even-worse-now-is-not-punished https://www.quora.com/Why-was-Microsoft-punished-for-violati...
- cm2187 11y agoI think it requires having a dominant position, which in the in app purchase market is pretty much the case (by revenues). Lots of android in the market but sold to people who couldn't tell the difference with iOS and wouldn't even know how to buy an app.
- cgm616 11y agoI think anti-trust also requires a non-privately administered market. In Apple's App Store, they own the servers serving the app market, giving them control. I don't think the government could force them to keep an app on their server and continue to serve it to consumers running their software if they didn't want to.
- diziet 11y agoActually, in terms of total revenue both markets are pretty close together now due to the larger install base on Android and ever increasing monetization of users.
- nitrogen 11y agoAnti-competitive behavior doesn't require a monopoly. There's collusion/price fixing, libel, and other ways to interfere in a business which are all illegal without having a monopoly. If we use cars as an analogy, we require car manufacturers to allow service by other mechanics, but we don't require the same for phones (yet). Car manufacturers do not have monopolies. At some point, asking, "Does Apple have a monopoly?" becomes the wrong question to ask.
- AznHisoka 11y agoIt's analogous to Google removing nytimes from their search results. To be honest though it's also anti competitive for big brands like uber to be able to bully their way to negative publicity while mom and pops are helpless if they are removed from an App Store or Google.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoAnti-competitive behaviors like this are really only an issue when done with a monopoly, which Apple does not have. That's how Apple can restrict the iPhone and iPad to a single browser and only allow browser skins/UIs within their app store. If Microsoft tried to make Internet Explorer the only browser permitted in Windows, it would be a very different story.
- boomlinde 11y agoA different story for sure, but I don't see how the difference between Windows and iOS plays to Apple's advantage here. Windows is something that I voluntarily run on my computer. If i don't like it, I wipe it off the disk and use a different operating system. If I wipe iOS off my phone I've voided my warranty as far as I understand.
- pedrorijo91 11y ago1. I believe that Uber would raise against such decision. I also believe that all the problems it could bring would make Apple back in that decision. They are not competitors, so they win anything for complicating life to Uber. 2. No one would switch to Android just because of that. 3. Yes, lots of negative publicity. That's why 1. would never be reached. Finally, one thing not mentioned: people would find a way to install the app without the app store. Every good hacker in the world would try to do it firstly, because every iphone user would be asking to be able to install Uber. And Apple doesn't want all bright minds trying to find flaws in their system for sure (I wouldn't at least)
- onion2k 11y ago2. No one would switch to Android just because of that. Because of losing Uber? No. Because they don't trust Apple not to remove other apps? Absolutely. Consistency, stability and trust are quite important to maintaining a brand. Apple arbitrarily removing apps would definitely harm their brand image, especially as they're positioning themselves as a market leader in fighting for their customers privacy and trust at the moment.
- pedrorijo91 11y agodidn't see that point. it's true, but I think consumers would take more than 1 app (even if it as big as Uber) to change. If the behaviour stars repeating of course people would. But Apple would be required by users to give an explanation for those actions. Still, all this post is kinda nonsense because it would never happen. It's more a karma bait lol
- rms_returns 11y ago> 1. They are not competitors, but Apple's arbitrary removal of the app from its AppStore without giving a valid reason will certainly make a legal case against them (unless Apple specifically mentions they can do so in their store's T&C which I don't know much about). >2. Yes, they would. In 2016, android is fully feature equivalent to Apple's iDevices, only reason you may not switch is that you are too lethargic and don't want to unlearn the iOS way of things. >3. Whether they will do it or not will depend on the negative publicity vis-a-vis impact on profits/bottom lines. If your bottom-lines hit the floor as no one is using an app to place cab booking orders, the last thing you will worry about is negative publicity. Apple, on the other hand, will worry about this publicity since it has a lot to loose from it.
- Spooky23 11y agoNo way. Plenty of people with lobbying power hate Uber, especially as they start attacking public transit. (Heavily unionized) Uber's valuation is dependent on growth and market dominance. Losing convenient access to a big piece of the market would a deep wound.