3 ms·
While this is a good goal, it's pretty clear this isn't the way to achieve it. It appears that the author hasn't thought it through - if the Facebook approach w
by nl 11y ago
While this is a good goal, it's pretty clear this isn't the way to achieve it. It appears that the author hasn't thought it through - if the Facebook approach was rejected, why should exactly the same thing (as far as I can see) be accepted from another company.
It seems to me that the experience with rapid mobile take-up in Africa indicates that market-based solutions can work, but the key is high levels of competition. My understanding is that in most of Africa the landline phone companies were government owned monopolies and under serviced rural areas which forced the private sector to act.
- dsr_ 11y agoThe FB approach: we will pay for some small amount of data that anyone can use, but we will determine what you can reach. We will make money by getting fees from the content providers we allow into this walled garden. The Steve Song approach: some of the profits of wireless providers will be mandated to go to a very low speed service that anyone can use for any purpose. The wireless providers may or may not make the money back from increased utilization by new and existing fee-paying subscribers who see increased value in the network. If it doesn't make money, it's not a problem: the social benefits outweigh the very small cost.
- nathanasmith 11y ago>>> the social benefits outweigh the very small cost. Of course they do, when it's somebody else's money. Bye bye karma or whatever it's called on this site.
- nl 11y agoI don't think dsr_ is arguing that the social benefits outweigh the very small cost - I think he's saying that's what Song's argument is. Bye bye karma or whatever it's called on this site. Pretty sure comments like that will get you downvoted and detract from anything you are saying on any site. I think pretty much everyone here would acknowledge how problematic that argument is.
- nathanasmith 11y ago>> I think he's saying that's what Song's argument is. I didn't say anything about whose argument it was just implying that it was specious. >> Pretty sure comments like that will get you downvoted I stopped worrying about internet points long ago.