7 ms·
When you think about it's the perfect tax: it's regressive (and the people in power love regressive taxes) and it effects the middle classes (and the people in
by paganel 11y ago
When you think about it's the perfect tax: it's regressive (and the people in power love regressive taxes) and it effects the middle classes (and the people in power don't care one bit about the middle classes, no-one I've heard of has ever said to him: "My ideal in life is to improve the condition of the middle class!" while I've heard of lots of people saying to themselves and others: "I want to eradicate poverty!").
A land tax would be regressive because it would have a bigger effect on middle class people compared to the 1%, because for a person representing the middle class a house purchase (which includes the land the house sits on) it's gonna be the biggest ever purchase from his/her life, while for a hedge-fund manager worth $5+ billion an extra money that he would have to pay on his Hamptons house is a blip in the ocean.
You mentioned a lot of economists, but you left out J.S. Mill, who at some point was strongly in favor of proportionally higher inheritance taxes. That kind of tax wold effect the hedge fund managers a little more, and it sounds fairer to the middle classes.
- nabla9 11y agoDo you think middle class people pay more for their house than they pay in other taxes during their lifetime? By the way. Higher property tax confiscates the profits from the ownership of the property and property prices decline accordingly. It's hard to follow trough all the consequences and feedback loops involved.
- lumberjack 11y agoThe regressiveness of the tax can be fixed. Most countries with land taxes have them so you only pay tax on land that is not part of your main residence. So in that case the middle class only starts paying the tax when they start investing some of their savings into real estate.
- Lazare 11y ago> When you think about it's the perfect tax: it's regressive Not really. (Tax incidence is one of those things that trips people up if they're not quite familiar with the subject.) One of the attractions is that it is progressive, and very, very difficult to pass on. Also note that we are talking about the value of the land, not the buildings, and that housing is only one of many uses land is put to. As for J.S. Mill, you might be surprised; he wrote that: "Landlords grow rich in their sleep without working, risking or economizing. The increase in the value of land, arising as it does from the efforts of an entire community, should belong to the community and not to the individual who might hold title." He and Henry George had many philosophical disagreements, but not about that.
- mcguire 11y agoI'm unclear on how it's difficult to pass on. The land value is higher because tenants are willing to pay more to use it.
- larsiusprime 11y agosee: http://kaalvtn.blogspot.co.uk/2013/01/g-lvt-would-benefit-rich-and-hurt-poor.html http://kaalvtn.blogspot.co.uk/2013/01/g-lvt-would-benefit-ri...
- mcguire 11y ago"b) The Economic Theory "Quite simply: any tax is borne by whoever is less price sensitive, the quantity demanded by consumers or the quantity supplied by suppliers/producers. "So a tax on tobacco (demand is little changed by increases in the total price, but suppliers have a minimum price which they need to receive in order to stay in business) is borne by smokers. [...] "Tenants are price-sensitive, they don't want to waste all their money on rent and will tend to choose the cheapest accommodation and will share if necessary. And the landlord? He cannot vary his output one jot, one home is one unit, either he rents it out at anything up to market rates (and we can safely assume that most of them do) or he demands more and receives nothing. If he is has fixed costs associated with that home (be it mortgage repayments or LVT) then he does not have the luxury of withdrawing the home from the market and leaving it empty, he has to rent it out for as much as he can (market rates). "This is often expressed with supply-demand curves, see e.g. Wiki." ...But of course the landlord can vary his output---in aggregate. He can take the home off the rental market. (If he actually is losing money at current rental rates, he will have no choice to do otherwise, luxury be damned.) He can tear down the house and run livestock on the property. He can convert it to commercial use. He can sell it to someone as a primary residence (which does take the house out of the rental market while taking <1 tenant out of the market). Further, he can not buy or build further rental property. And at some point, rental rates will rise because tenants are hardly perfectly price-flexible: the maximum duration of a daily commute is significantly less than 12 hours. Section b), "The Economic Theory" seems to be selectively ignoring economic theory. "c) Logic "We also know that rents are dictated by local average wages (after deducting PAYE and so on), plus extra if it's a nice area minus a bit if it's a grotty area. That is the beginning, middle and end of the matter. The landlord's actual cash costs are more or less completely irrelevant. As long as the actual or potential landlord can collect more in rent that it costs to provide and maintain the building he will rent it out (if not, he will abandon it). "If the rent is more than the maintenance costs, the balance is the site premium (or the location rent or whatever you want to call it), so the tenant pays rent sufficient to cover the cash costs and the site premium on top. If the government now decides to tax away the site premium, that is between the government and the landlord, this does not increase the rental value of the home by a single penny; the amount of rent which the tenant will pay is the same and so the landlord bears the tax. His remaining rental income after tax is, by definition, still enough to cover the maintenance costs and so he stays in business." But consider: * "Workers in the San Francisco-San Mateo-Redwood City Metropolitan Division had an average (mean) hourly wage of $33.34 in May 2014, about 47 percent above the nationwide average of $22.71, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics." [1] * "As of December 2015, average apartment rent within 10 miles of San Francisco, CA is $3484." [2] (10 miles from San Francisco appears to include a bit of Oakland and about halfway to San Mateo.) * "Median monthly gross residential rent in the United States was $905 in 2013 according to the Census ACS survey." [3] So workers are paying roughly 40 hours in residential rent in the US and 105 hours in the San Francisco area. (Must be a really nice area.) And for "The landlord's actual cash costs are more or less completely irrelevant," I believe that's a corollary of my conclusion to b). In fact, this entire article seems to be predicated on the idea that a rental property owner will continue to be a rental property owner no matter the economic consequences, although it does admit that "abandoning the property" is an option. In fact, this discussion leads me to believe that LVT is designed to raise rent prices by reducing the availability of rental property. [1] http://www.bls.gov/regions/west/news-release/occupationalemploymentandwages_sanfrancisco.htm http://www.bls.gov/regions/west/news-release/occupationalemp... [2] https://www.rentjungle.com/average-rent-in-san-francisco-rent-trends/ https://www.rentjungle.com/average-rent-in-san-francisco-ren... [3] http://www.deptofnumbers.com/rent/us/ http://www.deptofnumbers.com/rent/us/
- athenot 11y agoIt would also put an undue burden on those who still live off their own land. While their acre of vegetables & poultry may feed their family, they are not wealthy in the same way as an owner of 1 acre in a city.
- bitserf 11y agoYeah, just because one tiny fraction edge case might be affected, we should do absolutely nothing. The status quo of land ownership being an enabler of a rentier class pales in significance to the plight of subsistence farmers, which I have a hard time believing exist in any substantial number in developed countries. It's not like we could define classes of protected persons to balance out such effects? But no, it's better to do absolutely nothing on the off chance someone, somewhere might be negatively affected in the next millennium. Better the devil we know, right? No matter the imbalance and injustice to society, property rights and protection of capital derived from ownership, are sacrosanct. I hear this argument all the time, and without fail it's a Boomer who benefited from massive capital gains, or someone who bought when it was low. The Fuck You, Got Mine crowd. FWIW, I'm a homeowner, so in theory if I didn't care that we're creating a disenfranchised group on a massive scale, I should be against such a tax. But don't come here and pretend you really care at all about this contrived population of people who would suffer unduly.
- Spooky23 11y agoYou are absolutely correct. It may have been less regressive a century ago when capital was trapped in a particular geography due to the limitations of the banking and other systems. Its pretty easy technically to restore progressivism. - You introduce regulation to make it difficult and expensive to maintain shell companies. - Make compliance difficult for anonymous corporations and LLCs in states like Nevada. Make it difficult to bank if the principals are unknown. - Reduce taxation on repatriated dollars. - regressively tax ultra high incomes.
- mcguire 11y ago"- regressively tax ultra high incomes." More tax for incomes just above a threshold and less for higher?
- Spooky23 11y agoI think the income tax system works pretty fairly until it starts hitting the 250-300k range, where the net taxation drops as people at this range have more options to avoid taxation. (The story of Warren Buffet's effective rate vs. his secretary) So I think you need the ratchet the percentage higher and higher as you climb up.
- jholman 11y agoThe confusion here is that you're misusing the word "regressive". In the context of taxes, "regressive" means that the poor pay a higher percentage than the rich. That's because it's the opposite of "progressive", which means "super-linear", i.e. the rate progresses with your income. I think that what you actually meant was "progressively tax ultra high incomes".
- mcguire 11y agoYes, that's what I was asking about. Thanks!
- ubernostrum 11y ago