6 ms·
Sun-powered water splitter makes hydrogen tirelessly
- aaronbrethorst 17y agoHoly cow. can someone better educated than me comment on this? This sounds like it's a tremendous supply solution for hydrogen fuel cells. Is that accurate?
- InclinedPlane 17y agoTANSTAAFL, this is a significant improvement but the process of converting water into a supply of Hydrogen sitting on a shelf somewhere or otherwise readily available for use includes other costs than just the energy to hydrolyze water (though that is a big one). For example, the costs of land, the cost of water, the cost of the equipment and its maintenance, and especially the cost of collecting Hydrogen and storing it (generally under pressure). This may be a revolutionary breakthrough but until it's put into practice and we can judge all of these factors it's probably too soon to tell exactly how much of an impact it will have.
- camccann 17y agoRight. It's just a variety of solar power, converting the energy in sunlight into another form--in this case, chemical potential energy. The potential value lies in weighing practical considerations between different ways of storing solar energy--standard solar technologies tend to produce either heat or electricity, neither of which stores well.
- lucifer 17y agoThere are other considersions: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indium http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indium says that Indium is "rare". (Let us all pray that is not found only in the Middle East .. ;)
- peregrine 17y agoHow come nobody thinks about using hydrogen for powerplants? And keep it a closed system? Make hydrogen and oxygen from water+sun+new Tech. Burn hydrogen and oxygen and turn it into water vapor. Spin turbines. Collect water vapor and repeat?
- ars 17y agoI don't believe them. 60% is just not possible. You'll never hear about this technology again after this funding request, er, press release.
- pyre 17y agoDo we even know what pumping out all that water vapor will do to our environment? Sure, "it's just water," but won't that cause a shift in climate as well? Maybe not as severe as pumping out CO2 (since CO2 doesn't rain out of the atmosphere), but couldn't this affect local ecologies pretty severely in some areas (i.e. significant increases in rainfall)? I don't pretend to be an expert on the subject, but I've never heard anyone really comment on this other than the anti-global warming pundits spouting catch-phrases like "water is a greenhouse gas too."
- camccann 17y agoAt a global scale, the "rains out of the atmosphere" bit mostly covers it. Condensation and evaporation processes tend to make water vapor largely self-regulating, shifting around quantities of water that dwarf human factors. However, where does the article mention water vapor? They're doing electrolysis, i.e., cracking water molecules apart. The desired result is the liberated hydrogen; the waste is oxygen--hopefully O2, or if you're unlucky O3, which is a pollutant in the lower atmosphere.
- pyre 17y agoI was under the impression that when using hydrogen for fuel, the by-product was water (at least in automobiles). The article just triggered the question, I wasn't necessarily commenting on the technology. > At a global scale, the "rains out of the atmosphere" bit mostly covers it. Condensation and evaporation processes tend to make water vapor largely self-regulating, shifting around quantities of water that dwarf human factors. I was thinking more on a local level. I realize that water vapor will dump out of the atmosphere (unlike CO2) so it for the most part will not be a greenhouse gas. My question was on whether or not large amounts of water vapor being released from cars will cause local ecosystem changes. (i.e. If every vehicle in NYC or Los Angeles ran on hydrogen, would it cause average rainfall in the immediate or surrounding areas to increase? What about yearly average ratio of cloudy vs sunny days?) Obviously people in middle-America (for example) probably won't cause much of a local impact, but what about major urban centers?
- 17y ago
- RobertL 17y agoNuclear reactors make it even faster and more tirelessly when they melt down.
- houseabsolute 17y agoNo major reason to do it on gold or platinum, so basically they used these precious materials just for the hell of it? Odd.
- camccann 17y agoMany precious metals have useful qualities in terms of resisting corrosion, conducting heat or electricity, and such. In a lab doing this kind of work, they are likely to have those materials just lying around. Read it as "we used super-high-end electrode materials because we had them on hand, but the process doesn't actually require them".
- wglb 17y agoThere are major problems with hydrogen as a fuel, even presuming that this method becomes practical. First, it is more bulky than gasoline for the same energy value of fuel. Second, it is disastrously flammable, and you can't see the flame. Third, it causes metals to be brittle. These are major infrastructure and transportation issues that cast doubt on the viability of the "hydrogen economy" even if its production can be done without burning coal.
- Groxx 17y ago60% efficiency in splitting water apart? That's pretty incredible efficiency for anything solar powered. Whether or not you favor hydrogen as fuel, this may actually make it feasible. Heck, I wonder if this could surpass solar cells in efficiency & cost (no word on cost in the article), by burning the H & O or using a fuel-cell method with the hydrogen.
- ars 17y agoThey say they are making electricity for electrolysis. So why not just use that electricity directly? This article is nonsense. What they are claiming is impossible. 60% is just not possible with a single (i.e. non-layered) material.