3 ms·
This is true for the majority of word problems that exist today. Insofar as this is true, word problems don't really do what they set out to do: make the studen
by derefr 11y ago
This is true for the majority of word problems that exist today. Insofar as this is true, word problems don't really do what they set out to do: make the student understand why they need the formula, instead of merely pattern-matching.
I've always imagined a particular kind of "interactive word problem"—one you might be able to present in an interview, or on a computerized test—where the word problem itself contains no numbers that fit any sort of formula or pattern. Instead, the student is expected to notice that the real-world situation could be solved by analyzing it with the help of a certain algorithm—if they just had certain pieces of data. From this, they are then expected to ask for those pieces of data. The pieces they ask for might not all be available—in which case they're expected to come up with another method. (Also, data can be available that's entirely useless for any method of solving the problem.)
Imagine an episode of CSI: you see the blood spatter on the floor, the bullet holes in the walls. A real "word problem" would just describe those, then leave it to the student to come to the conclusion that they could use some formula they know to triangulate a source trajectory if they could get positionings for those spatter-marks and holes. Really, the asking for that data—the analysis step—is worth 90% of the mark; successfully applying the formula is just a bonus.