3 ms·
I taught freshman algebra for a semester at a big ten university. Therefore it's also a safe bet that I did a shit load of word problems myself when in school.
by analog31 11y ago
I taught freshman algebra for a semester at a big ten university. Therefore it's also a safe bet that I did a shit load of word problems myself when in school. Here's how you solve word problems:
1. From the text of the word problem, remember what section of the textbook it belongs to, and the standard form of equation to be solved in that section.
2. Match the parameters of the problem to the parameters of the equation.
3. Solve the equation.
For instance, "find the maximum" means creating an expression that has the form of a parabola (the only function they learned with an extremum, up to that point in the course), and solve for the vertex of the parabola.
- derefr 11y agoThis is true for the majority of word problems that exist today. Insofar as this is true, word problems don't really do what they set out to do: make the student understand why they need the formula, instead of merely pattern-matching. I've always imagined a particular kind of "interactive word problem"—one you might be able to present in an interview, or on a computerized test—where the word problem itself contains no numbers that fit any sort of formula or pattern. Instead, the student is expected to notice that the real-world situation could be solved by analyzing it with the help of a certain algorithm—if they just had certain pieces of data. From this, they are then expected to ask for those pieces of data. The pieces they ask for might not all be available—in which case they're expected to come up with another method. (Also, data can be available that's entirely useless for any method of solving the problem.) Imagine an episode of CSI: you see the blood spatter on the floor, the bullet holes in the walls. A real "word problem" would just describe those, then leave it to the student to come to the conclusion that they could use some formula they know to triangulate a source trajectory if they could get positionings for those spatter-marks and holes. Really, the asking for that data—the analysis step—is worth 90% of the mark; successfully applying the formula is just a bonus.
- HonestQ_902F 11y agoFrom your description and context, it sounds like you're describing elementary algebra and not abstract algebra. Honest question that sounds mean: isn't elementary algebra required for graduation from high school and admission to university? My university didn't offer elementary algebra, and I thought students without elementary algebra skills needed to at least start out in the community college system. In my public school system, the advanced math kids took elementary algebra in 8th grade, and the less mathematically inclined took it in 9th grade.
- analog31 11y agoYes, elementary algebra. Where I taught, they gave the incoming freshmen a math test, and the kids were put into Calculus, Algebra, or a "remedial" math course. Algebra was the lowest level course that could be offered by an accredited college, and the "remedial" kids eventually had to pass Algebra. This was a large state university, so the kids came in with a wide range of skills, from a state where there is a lot of variation in how math is taught in high school. They were bright, affluent kids. Many of them had taken algebra and even calculus, had gotten good grades, but had not really learned those subjects well enough to skip them in college. I had pretty much the same thoughts as you express, but as the semester progressed, I developed the opinion that these kids had been screwed by the system and still deserved a chance. They were not going to be engineers. Most of my students were planning to major in psychology or business.
- HonestQ_902F 11y agoI didn't mean to imply that the students weren't intelligent or hard working. I was just under the impression that most 4-year institutions required students to have passed elementary algebra in either high school or the community college system. It's unfortunate that the community college system has such a stigma attached to it. For students that have been failed by their high schools, it seems that a year in community college would be an ideal low-cost catch-up, rather than playing catch-up in a significantly more expensive 4-year institution and ending up likely to need a 5th year there.
- gohrt 11y agoYou seem to be complaining that your students are able to most-correctly (within the realm of their knowledge) solve the problems posed to them.
- analog31 11y agoAh, good question. Most of my students did OK, and were generally good at doing whatever was necessary to get a decent grade. My complaint had more to do with how the problems were posed -- they seem to create a rather stilted view of what math is about.
- dclowd9901 11y agoIt now occurs to me that algorithm questions during interviews are exactly the adult version of word problems in math and I utterly sympathize with students. Though I question the validity of an algorithm question for any position outside of a researcher or crypto or compression scientist, and I don't question the need for word questions in math education.