> forests are renewable by definition, being made up of plants capable of reproduction Ever heard of soil erosion/degradation? Check out what happened to Easte

> forests are renewable by definition, being made up of plants capable of reproduction Ever heard of soil erosion/degradation? Check out what happened to Easter Island. It takes thousands of years to turn a desert into a jungle, so in practical terms forests are non-renewable. > pure water is not a non-renewable resource. Again, on a practical timeline clean fossil water is unreplenishable: where do you think it comes from? And what do you think happens to a lake near an abandoned gold mine? Several of your points have nothing to do with the topic, i.e. having enough resources to sustain the ever growing population: what difference does it make either oil is biological in origin or not?