2 ms·
>Most people who buy their homes for long-term buy it to settle in their neighborhoods and have kids go to the same school, not speculate on price increases and
by epistasis 11y ago
>Most people who buy their homes for long-term buy it to settle in their neighborhoods and have kids go to the same school, not speculate on price increases and profit from them.
IF this is the true purpose of Proposition 13, then it would be written far differently. (Greater than 2%, no commercial real estate included, no passing on to children). People are also allowed to sell their home for more than the assessed tax value, precisely because people speculate on price increases of their homes. If that wasn't one of the primary reasons behind Proposition 13 then people would have been OK with only being able to sell their home at the assessed value.
Really though the point of Proposition 13 was to just pay less taxes, "staying in your home" doesn't really come into play. Defending it along those lines is deceptive, and propagates a false narrative.
- prostoalex 11y ago> People are also allowed to sell their home for more than the assessed tax value, precisely because people speculate on price increases of their homes. If that wasn't one of the primary reasons behind Proposition 13 then people would have been OK with only being able to sell their home at the assessed value. I am not sure what you're describing is correct - each time I bought a property in California the assessed tax value next year was precisely the sale price. Here's what California has to say on it: http://www.lao.ca.gov/reports/2012/tax/property-tax-primer-112912.aspx http://www.lao.ca.gov/reports/2012/tax/property-tax-primer-1... The process that county assessors use to determine the value of real property was established by Proposition 13. Under this system, when real property is purchased, the county assessor assigns it an assessed value that is equal to its purchase price, or “acquisition value.”
- epistasis 11y agoYou misunderstand what I wrote. Right now, Prop 13 beneficees have an assessed value of, say $300,000, on a $1,000,000 house. They can sell the house for $1,000,000. If Prop 13 were actually about keeping people in their homes, then after taking advantage of below-market taxes for so long, they wouldn't be allowed to sell for more than a small percentage more than the tax assessed value. But Prop 13 is not about keeping people in their homes, it's a selfish grab to not pay taxes, drive up home values, and profit on both ends.
- pfarnsworth 11y agoThis wouldn't solve the problem of state revenue. Of course, it would solve YOUR problem of being able to afford a house because house prices would be fixed, right? Except that there would be way too much competition because now everyone could afford house prices that were fixed to 1960s levels, and you probably still wouldn't be able to get your house.
- prostoalex 11y ago> they wouldn't be allowed to sell for more than a small percentage more than the tax assessed value This just has a bad smell to it - not only you're inviting corruption and avoidance into the deal (the buyer is asked to bring the check for the assessed value and a suitcase of cash to the deal), the actual revenue collected by the state would fall, and the federal government is likely to contest this setup as it stands to lose out on capital gains. > Right now, Prop 13 beneficees have an assessed value of, say $300,000, on a $1,000,000 house. Assuming a very healthy and robust real estate market that grows gangbusters 15% every single year and never falls, it would take 9 years for a $300,000 property to grow into $917,706. It would go over the $1,000,000 sticker during year 10. Of course, this is assuming ever-lasting 15% valuation increase and no price correction whatsoever, but even in this ideal market the owner has lived there for 9+ years and does not fall qualify for your definition of "keeping people in their home"? Even when he sells, the cash he has on hand is enough to (surprise!) buy a comparable house, so this crazy speculation scheme is only doable once in life.
- pfarnsworth 11y agoYou are wrong. The assessed value is the sale price of the house.