4 ms·
Considering California has a pretty robust real estate market with properties changing hands often, therefore resetting the price for Prop 13 purposes, how much
by prostoalex 11y ago
Considering California has a pretty robust real estate market with properties changing hands often, therefore resetting the price for Prop 13 purposes, how much actual revenue is lost?
The biggest beneficiary of Prop 13 would be someone who bought his home in 1970s and never sold it since then. Does that describe a lot of the neighbors?
- _delirium 11y agoIn commercial real estate, it's become standard practice in California to never allow properties to legally change hands, in order to avoid the Prop-13 reset. Instead, commercial property is owned by holding companies, and ownership of the holding companies is bought and sold, but the property itself doesn't undergo an official real-estate sale.
- throwaway6497 11y agoIt doesn't make sense to allow commercial real-estate companies to take advantage of prop-13. I thought, the whole point of Prop-13 was to ensure that old folks don't get thrown out their homes.
- epicureanideal 11y agoTheoretically it could also be a 75 year old man in his 55 year old corner grocery store. Just playing devil's advocate here. I agree with you.
- maxerickson 11y agoIs this process well documented? This is like leaving the front door off the law, not like putting a back door into it, so I wonder if it is more of an internet rumor than an actual way to avoid change of ownership. Maybe people do it but it is fraud?
- _delirium 11y agoThere was at least one court case over it, in 2008, regarding Michael Dell buying a hotel in Santa Monica via a holding company, where he prevailed in court: http://www.santamonicadispatch.com/2013/05/prop-13-gives-edge-to-dell/ http://www.santamonicadispatch.com/2013/05/prop-13-gives-edg... It seems it's more complex than what I implied, though. The property needs to not only be owned by a holding company, but sales of the holding company have to be structured in such a way that overall ownership of the holding company isn't deemed to have changed. If the above article is correct, that's triggered when a new owner acquires a majority stake. So to avoid triggering a change in ownership in this case, Dell structured the sale so that he, his wife, and another business partner all bought interests in the company, split so that no single purchaser acquired more than 49%.
- ForHackernews 11y ago...that sounds like a legal loophole that should be closed.
- prostoalex 11y agoI could see how a publicly-traded REIT would argue that the property it owns changes owners every second, and in that case it makes little sense to include rental properties under Prop 13 umbrella. Couple of arguments against such exemption that I can see are * major real estate property owners can make a case (in court of necessary) that their property prices have not increased as much as single-family residential prices, due to the nature of the commercial market (fewer buyers, larger amounts, larger variety of the market to find decent comparables) * as property tax is deductible, the revenue would just restructure - what will be collected via property tax would then be deducted at the end of the year from income tax. I guess even in that case owners would be supportive, as property taxes typically go directly to the municipalities, while income taxes are spent by some politicians in Sacramento, but then why would Sacramento be in favor of the exemption that would lower its collected revenue?
- epistasis 11y ago>Considering California has a pretty robust real estate market with properties changing hands often Says who? >The biggest beneficiary of Prop 13 would be someone who bought his home in 1970s and never sold it since then. Does that describe a lot of the neighbors? This describes huge chunks of many many neighborhoods. When I bought a house in 2010, >75% of the homes on the market were the original owner from the 60s or 70s.
- pfarnsworth 11y agoThis is the thing that no one mentions anymore because they lazily blame Prop 13. The real estate market has been great since at least 1999 in the entire Bay Area, except for some areas that suffered the housing crash. Even during the housing bust, there was turnover from the short sales and foreclosures. It's a myth but people like to perpetuate the myth because they don't want to do the research.