11 ms·
Company Makes $70M Selling Random Stuff on Amazon
- nefitty 11y agoThe opportunities on Amazon are exciting. The company is still growing, continually gaining customers. As far as I can glean it has recently been pushing to make international sales easier, which is a whole 'nother pot of gold to start snatching coins from.
- stickfigure 11y agoI know this gauche on HN, but... I'm on a macbook air. Between the "skip ad" popup and the top bar that eats the top 2/3 of my screen, the article is unreadable. After some scrolling around the top bar seems to have gone away, but I've already lost interest. Please stop making your articles unreadable. It's not like I've disabled javascript. Actually... I suspect it would be more readable that way. Hmmmm.
- 300bps 11y agoOn an iPhone the window for the article is about a half inch high and there was no obvious way to make it bigger.
- elorant 11y agoThat's why I love the Reader View feature in Firefox. I use it all the time, even at sites with good UX/UI practices.
- Illniyar 11y agoI can attest that reading it with js disabled is a much better expietence
- Magnets 11y agoI closed the tab then later reloaded the page and it completely blocked it saying I needed to login to view it. Clearing cookies fixed it, but wow.
- finnn 11y agothis site is fucking unbearable.
- x5n1 11y agoWonder how is that after tax net income. But yes there has to be a unicorn there and this is one of those exceptions. Most Amazon retailers are complaining about getting shafted.
- mattedwards984 11y agoThis is a very inspiring story! Love it.
- justincormack 11y agoAnd Amazon makes $200m or so from them, based on the margin figures.
- jsnell 11y agoThat $70M is clearly their total sales, not their net income. And I'm pretty certain that when Amazon is acting purely as a marketplace intermediary, they won't be counting the full value of the order as revenue. So Amazon is making something like $7-10M a year from them.
- mdorazio 11y agoI'm trying to figure out what their net income looks like, and I don't think it's much. They've got 16 customer service reps, over 100 packers, who knows how many other employees, refunds and replacements to deal with, plus the warehouse lease that all have to come out of their margin. What they're doing is still impressive, but they're not taking home Apple-level profits any time soon.
- oneloop 11y ago10-15% of 70m is 7-10.5m
- KenanSulayman 11y agoRequiring registration for reading the article is BS
- solidangle 11y agoBlocking their cookies and Javascript codes circumvents that. This can be done using NoScript.
- smoyer 11y agoI've got uBlock running and didn't notice there was a registration page at all.
- Freak_NL 11y agoDitto. Nothing at all with uBlock Origin, just the article.
- ambicapter 11y agoI use uMatrix and it wholly blocked me from opening the page?
- gorhill 11y agoBe sure your uMatrix HOSTS files are up to date, I can see a `inc.com` in the packaged Peter Lowe's list, it seems this has been removed at some point.
- teh_klev 11y agoArchive.is to the rescue: http://archive.is/oJUKB http://archive.is/oJUKB
- spangry 11y agoThat's awesome, and good on those guys. Markets can only be competitive when information is ubiquitous and barriers to entry are low. This, I think, is one of the less talked about revolutions brought about by the internet: the creation of hyper-competitive markets that have led to superior outcomes for consumers.
- timrpeterson 11y agoMedia: journalism, music, videos is definitely a hypercompetitive market enabled by the Internet. It's just unclear whether it's "good" for consumers.
- smt88 11y ago> information is ubiquitous The only problem is that much of the information isn't reliable, which creates competitive markets that aren't always good for the consumer.
- benevol 11y ago> superior outcomes for consumers You're not factoring in the fact that the Internet creates huge monopolies (just like money also has a natural monopolizing effect; in other words "rich get richer, poor get poorer"). We end up with a couple of huge Internet companies which will increase their pressure as soon as they are sure that they are "strong enough" (meaning: protected from healthy competition which usually favors the consumer). Example: Amazon - they currently keep only a very tiny margin, because they are still about increasing their overall market power. Once they have maximized that, they will use their power to increase their margin and all players (including the consumer) will feel their heat.
- icebraining 11y agoOnce they have maximized that, they will use their power to increase their margin and all players (including the consumer) will feel their heat. That's the claim, where's the evidence? What exactly prevents anyone from entering the market once Amazon raises prices? I'm not a fan of Amazon and I don't think I've ever even bought something from them, but I think there's too much paranoia over market dominance.
- nomkaaoa 11y agoSeems like an awful lot of trouble for 3-6% net after COGS. From that, they have to pay their employees, rents, lawyers, etc. all with the threat that on any given day there could be wild fluctuations in their revenue. Good luck to them, but let's see how long they last. Amazon, unfortunately is a zero sum game.
- jsnell 11y agoThose costs (employees, rents, lawyers, etc) are already included. You're thinking of gross margin which is indeed based just on COGS. But the number in the infographic is net margin, and therefore covers all expenses of running the business.
- pmorici 11y agoAre you sure you aren't confusing net and gross? The graphic in the article pretty clearly says, "3-6% net profit margin per item". I would take that to mean after accounting for expenses. Meaning they make a profit of between 2-4 million on their 70 million in sales.
- kgwgk 11y agoIf it is really the net margin it doesn't make sense to say "per item". Maybe this metric includes all the variable costs (like product acquisition cost, salaries directly linked to handling the orders and cost of delivery) but there are still fixed costs that have to be paid from that "net."
- jamesfe 11y agoSeems like a lot of trouble until you have $70 million in your pocket, and then it doesn't.
- nomkaaoa 11y agotouché
- benevol 11y agoIn the long run, you can a) control the production of the good (or service) b) control the interface to the consumer Everything else are middlemen and will disappear. These guys' suppliers do a) and Amazon does b). These guys are simple middlemen who add no real/critical value and will be crushed by Amazon. Just a matter of time.
- tyingq 11y agoIn the real world, though, opportunities arise that neither "a" nor "b" take advantage of. One of them is noted in the article...grey area product sources. If "b" isn't taking the time to find distressed inventory, there's an opportunity for a middleman to do so, and undercut "b". There's also some value added where the middleman has expertise or something to offer that neither 'a' nor 'b' has. That could be better marketing (product photos, how-to videos), or better support (more lenient return policy, deeper technical support, etc), bundling multiple products together, niche sales, or something else. Generally, successful middlemen find something missing between "a" and "b" and fill the gap. Is it a war of escalation, where either "a" or "b" can react? Sure...but typically middlemen can move faster. Or, in short, they exist for a reason, and I don't see that the internet age changed anything about that other than pace of change.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jamesfe 11y agoIn a perfect world, yes, the producer controls the amount created and the specified price of the product, but the article mentions that producers sometimes sell to one market for more than another. If the delta between these two costs is large enough, these "simple middlemen with no value" step in and earn some money. I don't see any reason for Amazon to crush them - Amazon is getting a cut of their profits and they effectively outsource all liability to another company. I also don't think they're simple. They've identified a constant in our world - inequality in either income or product, and they're exploiting it for the (arguable) benefit of the consumer. What they're doing takes experience and connections (to the logistics & supply chain) and it takes intelligence and engineering (to predict supply/demand and price appropriately). Do I think these guys are inventing a world-changing technology? No, but let's not underestimate - they are far from simple and they will likely never go away.
- salgernon 11y agoI feel that this is an untenable situation and business model. When people first took to buying their "random crap" via amazon, it was at least backed by an amazon customer service experience that defaulted to very good - amazon prime shipping, consistent shipping and packaging, consistent return policies. But once these marketplace sellers came into being, the qualify of the experience is on the whole, lacking. Years ago, my family would use a particular salad dressing enough that when we found it on Amazon as a "send me a case of this every three months" thing, we were happy with that. It was marginally cheaper than buying at the store, but it was far more convenient At some point, we started receiving things from sellers that were obviously not Amazon themselves, and then endless emails asking us to rate their service, etc. Sometimes the product would be poorly package or damaged in shipping. Once it seemed like something had maybe turfed off their pantry shelf into a box to send us. It was annoying but not worth our time to 'fix', so we just canceled that order. But lately it seems like things have been getting harder to deal with when these third party sellers are involved. I don't want to save $1.37 on a $200 router that I receive in obviously opened-and-returned condition and missing parts, and then receive an insulting letter from the (actual) seller about it somehow being my fault and saying that I should pay the return cost. It may be possible go get amazon involved in resolving this - BUT IT IS NOT WORTH MY TIME. At some point, it was easier and cheaper to use Amazon for all these types of purchases, but Amazon Marketplace is hurting their brand. Weakest link and all that. (Maybe we'll get a return to brick & mortar stores for radio-shack or similar things.)
- benzofuran 11y agoI'd love to see an "Amazon Only" mode that was a switch on the main page to only show the store for sold by or fulfilled by Amazon. I'm sure this can be done somehow and would make the experience much better. The crap 1000 review emails would be nice to disappear as well.
- johansch 11y agoThe lack of a switch like this is especially annoying for people who live in "other countries". Like Sweden, in my case. Amazon gladly ships here (from UK, France, Germany, Spain, US, etc) - with quite decent product and shipment prices. However, all the search results are polluted by these non-Amazon sellers' results, who 90% of the time don't even have an international shipment process. In the end, this just makes me avoid Amazon and go somewhere else.
- moldinaga 11y agoDo you really not understand that 70M in revenue <> "making" 70M?
- mrweasel 11y agoKinda hard to tell, loads of people in the tech industry struggles with the concept of profit and focus solely on revenue.
- moldinaga 11y agoCan you really not understand that 70M in revenue <> "making" 70M? Glad I'm not your business partner. :)
- moldinaga 11y agoDo you really not understand that 70M in revenue <> "making" 70M?
- arbuge 11y ago>>Unlike eBay, where each vendor maintains a separate listings page, Amazon tidily groups its Marketplace sellers by item, hiding away the inferior offers, to showcase the best deals up front. (In seller parlance, landing the number-one spot is called "getting the buy box.") It's a key difference. For example we purchase shipping labels on Amazon and Ebay. On Amazon it's harder to know what you're getting unless you carefully check the marketplace seller you're buying from. The intuitive process of just reordering what worked for you previously from your purchase history doesn't work on Amazon as it does on Ebay. All too often, a different seller now owns the buy box with an inferior product.
- simonswords82 11y agoI've built software for companies that sell on Amazon exactly the way these guys work. The products sold were different but the logic exactly the same. Write software that intelligently guesses the optimum prices and automates listing on Amazon. There's more to it than that, but this is the crux. This is a TOUGH business to be in. They're under attack from every conceivable angle every single day: 1) Customers complaining on Amazon, often not legitimately 2) Minimum wage employees doing the "picking and packing" to ship to customers not turning up for work, making mistakes or worse still stealing from the company 3) The postal service letting them down not delivering an item which results in more 1) customers complaining 4) Suppliers spotting that my clients are on to a good thing and trying to rip them off, gouging them on prices or just messing them about in general 5) Margins so tight that they squeak when they walk. This business is all about volume of sales because of those margins. Which means you need to have lots of people, floor space, and other associated fixed overheads to achieve said volume As if all of that isn't bad enough, you're in the pocket of Amazon. A company who at any given point in time for any reason they deem fit could simply shut your Amazon listings down and just like that your business dies. I'm sure they're doing great, and I wish these guys well, but holy shit is this a tough business to scale.
- danieltillett 11y agoThis is why you stay out of low markin businesses if you can at all costs - easier said than done of course.
- simonswords82 11y agoIndeed. I'd probably add low barrier to entry as yet another reason this business model sucks too!
- TrevorJ 11y agoI wonder how long it will be before Amazon starts truly transitioning towards becoming the end to end supplier/seller. It seems to me that they have strategically used third party sellers to bankroll the needed infrastructure and provide vast amounts of data to mine. Third party sellers can't stay on Amazon forever unless they have margin, and it's a near-certainty that Amazon could capitalize on that margin better than a third party reseller can.