4 ms·
Dogs we with us before the concept of culture, possibly before what we know as language. Cats joined us with the birth of agriculture. Pigs and cows have neve
by sandworm101 11y ago
Dogs we with us before the concept of culture, possibly before what we know as language. Cats joined us with the birth of agriculture. Pigs and cows have never been partners in the way that dogs and cats have.
"New research shows babies have a handle on the meaning of different dog barks – despite little or no previous exposure to dogs."
https://news.byu.edu/news/babies-understand-dog-speak-byu-study-finds https://news.byu.edu/news/babies-understand-dog-speak-byu-st...
I've seen this effect demonstrated amongst people on opposite sides of the planet, with totally different languages and cultures. We can all understand the mood and intent of a dog's bark. You don't even need to be a dog person.
- gozur88 11y agoWhich is all sort of unrelated to the point. Sure, in some cultures dogs are working animals. In others they're pets. That doesn't mean it's somehow wrong that yet other people see them as livestock.
- Nutmog 11y agoThere's a missing part in your reasoning. Why does a history of people understanding dogs imply that we shouldn't eat them? Should we never eat animals (or plants?) that people in many cultures and times could understand? What connects understanding and eating? Is it OK for other animals to eat them? Even if we feed the dogs to those other animals? Don't chickens fall into the same category as dogs? People everywhere live with them wandering around their house, then from time to time they eat one. Ignoring any other factors, would it be OK to eat a person or dog who had some brain damage so that nobody could understand the mood or intent of anything they communicated? Would it be OK for a person with an inability to understand dogs' (or people's) moods to eat them? What if a new breed of cow was developed that could get along with people the way dogs do. Would that elevate it to the status of being un-eatable, or not because it doesn't have the long history of people understanding it like dogs do? These might sound like snarky questions, but their answers would help paint a clearer picture of your idea which, as you've presented it, doesn't make sense to me. Personally, I wouldn't eat dog because I can imagine all the dogs I've met and feel some emotional connection with. But that's just my personal history. If I was the only one like that, I still wouldn't eat them. You seem to be saying that if you (or your culture) were the only person/culture who had dogs as pets, then you would be willing to eat dogs. You also implied that it's OK to kill humans ("no sympathy"). Is it OK to kill dogs too as long as we don't eat them?
- fractallyte 11y agoWhat your detractors (and downvoters) seem to miss is that dogs occupy a unique position of partnership alongside humans - and have done, as you say, since pre-history. That's most certainly not the same thing as 'livestock'. Treating a companion-in-survival as food is taboo in every sense of the word. It's emotionally tantamount to cannibalism. That's why it's unacceptable, and rightfully reviled.