3 ms·
I've always felt that both sides' arguments about gun control are frustratingly uncertain, so this data does in fact support my opinion! :D Has there been any
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
I've always felt that both sides' arguments about gun control are frustratingly uncertain, so this data does in fact support my opinion! :D
Has there been any significant effort to really comprehensively evaluate the data around gun violence and gun control? I've seen arguments on both sides that seem convincing given the data they present, but they always seem to be cherry-picked to support the "right" conclusion. Nobody is interested in evaluating first and then making policy.
- hga 11y agoIt's genuinely hard. You have to go to a granularity of counties at minimum, and pro-gun John Lott is the only guy I know who's done that. E.g. look at this by state and hit the column sorting buttons: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States_by_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_Sta... Maryland, which I lived next to while in Arlington, VA for a dozen years, and Missouri where I was born, raised, and have retired to, have very similar statistics with very different gun control regimes. Just looked at racial makeup on their separate state pages, and Maryland has almost 3 times the percentage of blacks, which would not at all support a thesis that they're generically overly prone to murder with guns. Or look at Joplin, and at the other end of I-44, which replaced Route 66, is St. Louis, just now the murder capital of the US. Night and day, same gun control laws or lack thereof, e.g. no more difficult to buy them than anywhere else in the US and easy to obtain concealed carry licenses.
- geggam 11y agoShould tell you gun violence is more a symptom of other issues. I grew up where you could go deer hunting and leave school early to do so. Rule was you had to put your gun / bullets in the principals office. Same place those of us who were in trouble sat. Unattended. 50+ guns / couple hundred bullets. No one ever got shot nor was it ever even talked about.
- hga 11y agoWhen my father went to high school here in the late '40s, he and his peers would keep their long guns in their lockers for the same reason, same result with absolutely no control by the school authorities. The late Supreme Court justice Scalia, 3 years younger, related in the oral arguments of Heller how he'd carry his target rifle on the NYC subway to and from his school/JROTC? rifle range. When I attended in the late '70s, the JROTC rifles were in a safe to which we did not have the combination (well, they were government property), now they use air rifles :-(.
- davidw 11y ago> Has there been any significant effort to really comprehensively evaluate the data around gun violence and gun control? http://www.businessinsider.com/congressional-ban-on-gun-violence-research-rewnewed-2015-7 http://www.businessinsider.com/congressional-ban-on-gun-viol...
- unethical_ban 11y agoNote this ban does not apply on any private think tank, billionaire, university, or public institutions other than the CDC.
- tclmeelmo 11y ago> Has there been any significant effort to really comprehensively evaluate the data around gun violence and gun control? The NRC did a review in 2004 that is probably the closest to what you're seeking: http://www.nap.edu/catalog/10881/firearms-and-violence-a-critical-review http://www.nap.edu/catalog/10881/firearms-and-violence-a-cri... It's not the comprehensive review of the literature you're looking for, but more recently in 2011, the Justice Department put out a report that might also be of interest: http://bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/fv9311.pdf http://bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/fv9311.pdf