4 ms·
I had a customer-facing programming job (something like a technical consultant). I had to speak English understandably -- even over the phone -- and be a polish
by paulddraper 11y ago
I had a customer-facing programming job (something like a technical consultant). I had to speak English understandably -- even over the phone -- and be a polished, likeable, and competent representative for the company.
It's hard to imagine how this could be done without "flawed human judgement".
Some jobs might be form-filling or widget-building in a dark basement, and you might be able to get away with this. But a lot of jobs are not that.
- lsc 11y agoThe rules for sales are... different, but sales (and to a lesser extent, consulting, at least the "make the customer feel special" part of consulting) exists in what most of us consider to be a kind of ethical gray area. You're trying to tell the customer "I'm one of you" Most technical jobs are not like that. Most have pretty minimal social requirements. If you can't work with a programmer who doesn't look like you, I'd argue that the problem is with you, not with the person who looks different. Every time I argue that competency should be more important than 'cultural fit' people bring up the example of the asshole. But the asshole isn't usually the one rejected for 'cultural fit' - assholes usually do fairly well during the interview.
- geofft 11y agoAnd there are technical ways to find the asshole. Send them some bad code for review and see how they review it; ask them to work with the author to get it merged. (Enough code review happens in open-source projects over email/GitHub, over text, with pseudonyms, that having it be anonymous is entirely realistic.) Alternatively, keep an eye out for asshole behavior -- to any employee, not just those on the same team -- during the first few weeks, and be willing to fire.
- analog31 11y agoI'm not talking about you, per se, but about hiring for such a job. One could justify a face-to-face interview for a job like that, but if blind hiring became commonplace, you might have to settle for second best in terms of technical ability. This is already typical of technical sales jobs.
- paulddraper 11y agoAnd second best in terms of sales ;)
- geofft 11y agoAs the article says, the first rounds of interviewing (seeing if you have the technical skills to consult) can be done without seeing you. That sort of thing routinely involves human judgment, but does not need it. Your personability, which requires human judgment, can be measured afterwards. It seems to me that the same argument could be made against blind orchestra auditions. You could potentially play your instrument amazingly well, but also be unpresentable on stage. Maybe you refuse to wear clothes that fit. Maybe you pick your nose during rests. Maybe you shake your leg subconsciously. If those are real problems, they can be found after hearing a good audition, and they won't allow unconscious bias to interpret the human judgment of whether the audition is in fact good.