5 ms·
My understanding is the government is generally supposed to pay for the cost of external requests to private entities, should they choose to bill for it.... Unf
by tracker1 11y ago
My understanding is the government is generally supposed to pay for the cost of external requests to private entities, should they choose to bill for it.... Unfortunately, the cost of compliance for Apple is lost future revenue, not just the technical costs of the gimped iOS version.
- progressive_dad 11y agoThe specifics are important. If I said, "If a police officer gives you a lawful order do you have to comply?" you would immediately say, "yes". Now what if I said, "If a police officer demands that an entire neighborhood be subject to lengthy interrogation and be held for 24 hours in custody in order to solve a murder that took place there." You'd probably say that's ridiculous. That's essentially what I view to be the case here. In theory the procedure may be perfectly "lawful" but in practice is clearly overreach. We need case law around this. I believe this is as clear a case of overreach as Apple could wish for. Finally, I believe it should be legal precedent set in public for once.
- harryh 11y agoRequesting a trivial modification to a piece of software is overreach?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- progressive_dad 11y agoIt becomes non-trivial due to the marketing of their devices as secure systems. Just as with the burden of proof in defamation actions is higher in the case of a public figures, the "triviality" of the modification in this case is held to a higher standard due to the purpose of the product. * I can't reply below this threshold but I'm enjoying the back and forth. People buy iphones because they believe that there are no ways to "trivially" access their personal information. Even for Apple to do so would be a breach of that trust. See: "Uber God Mode"
- harryh 11y agoPeople buy iPhones because they think that the FBI can't ever compel Apple to extract data from them? And even if that's true (which I really don't think it is) it's not a good enough reason. Say I started a bank and marketed my bank as an especially secure one. "Even the FBI will never be able to see your bank records. I won't let them!" I bet some customers might be interested in that. Just because I had marketed my bank that way doesn't mean my bank would gain some special legal protection against warrants.
- criddell 11y agoThe big difference between the two is that the banks have the information and are already subject to lots of record keeping regulations and so it is not an undue burden for them to comply with a subpoena demanding information. Apple does not currently have what the FBI is asking for and to comply would mean creating that software. If the government wants to pass a law requiring phone makers like Apple to include a back door, then that's what they should do. For me, this boils down to whether or not people are allowed to have strong encryption.
- progressive_dad 11y ago> For me, this boils down to whether or not people are allowed to have strong encryption. Its easy to see why DOD originally classified it as a munition. Video games have become a powerful tool for storytelling, education, performance art, and immersive experiences for a long time but they started out as artillery simulators and a means to practice war games. That mentality pervades and we still see Jump, Shoot, and Run as the primary dynamic by which we function in these amazing experiences. You're fighting against human instinct and hundreds of thousands of years of evolution. Against Dunbar's number, the core mechanic of trust and social engagement for millenia. I hope you're right, but I don't think it will be the sea-change you're expecting. Look at the adoption of bitcoin and remember that law enforcement is a retro-grade function of society. Underfunded and always behind the zeitgeist. We don't ask the secret service to build the president's merchandising website, and we shouldn't expect the FBI to be able to articulate or comprehend the, "triviality" of undermining strong encryption.
- tracker1 11y agoI'm not saying it isn't overreach, I agree that it is... the 4th and 5th amendments indicate this, as well as other reasonable interpretations of the law. I was only responding to the gp, in that it would be billable, but the real "cost" may be incalculable... not to mention the damage to near term and long term security, and future incursions into privacy built upon yielding here.