5 ms·
New Anti-Piracy Windows 7 Update "Phones Home" to Microsoft Every 90 Days
- barrkel 17y agoKB71033 doesn't sound like a valid KB number - it's way out of sequence with current KBs, which are approaching KB900000 or so.
- stingraycharles 17y agoFurthermore, all the references to KB71033 found by Google are about this exact same phone-home news: http://www.google.com/search?q=KB71033 http://www.google.com/search?q=KB71033
- prewett 17y agoAnd, as of right now (1:39pm 2/11 CST), a link to this stingraycharles' comment is #1 on Google if you follow his link.
- invisible 17y agoIt's rather like an infinite loop, no?
- patrickgzill 17y agoFor all we know, MSFT gave different KB numbers to different people they briefed on the issue; allowing them to easily track which person is talking about it/leaking/being influential.
- roc 17y ago(Author)'s basically describing WAT. So while the number might be off, the patch itself exists. http://windowsteamblog.com/blogs/genuinewindows/archive/2010/02/11/windows-activation-technologies-update-for-windows-7.aspx http://windowsteamblog.com/blogs/genuinewindows/archive/2010... Edit: pronoun fail.
- wglb 17y agoLauren is a he. That is a picture of him on the bike. And a very interesting fellow.
- JadeNB 17y agoI am a male 'Loren' by birth, but 'Lauren' to everyone who has ever tried to write down my name with explicit guidelines. (When I was young, my mother once accidentally almost enrolled me in a girls' school, which was delighted at the opportunity to welcome little Lauren.) As such, I have little to offer in this discussion other than: Thanks for helping to keep the pronouns straight. I also always struggle with the temptation to say "What he's saying is …" when referring to an anonymous poster --I know it may not be the correct word, but it's so much easier than finding a gender-neutral re-phrasing. I quite like the grandparent's suggestion of '(Author)'s' as a substitute for 'his' or 'her' (or 'his or her').
- wglb 17y agoAnd I have learned recently that "their" is acceptable in this context as well. I probably wouldn't have made the comment other than the fact that I did some work with him back in the 80s.
- sgk284 17y agoHey there, there are a few things the author got wrong but the KB will be KB971033. I work on Windows Update, so can't really comment on anything else about it... but if you want to keep an eye out for it, that's the KB to look for. Anything else you need to know about it (i.e. release dates) can be read about on the Windows Team Blog. Disclaimer: I don't represent Microsoft.
- tomh- 17y agoThis is absolutely ridiculous, I wonder how long it takes before Apple to take over this behavior. Crackers will always be able to outsmart Microsoft. The only victims of this technology are paying customers, like me. Maybe it's time to cancel my Action Pack and Websitespark memberships and use software from a company who trusts its own customers and doesn't treat its customers as potential pirates.
- eli 17y agoSeeing as you can't buy a mac without OS X (and that you can't buy OS X for a non-mac), I imagine it's much less of an issue. Doesn't quite seem worth the effort to engineer a DRM system just to block people skimping on the occasional $29 upgrade.
- roc 17y agoWhy would you expect Apple to follow suit? They don't even have activation codes. They already treat their paying customers the way you're asking to be treated.
- tomh- 17y agoApple has other products which could incorporate this behavior (not trusting their customers) like itunes content, iWorks or potentially jail broken iphones. I mean there are various ways for Apple to gain more control over their users.
- alextgordon 17y agoAs far as I know, Apple doesn't even make a product with online activation. They use serial numbers or nothing at all. They just don't care about controlling their users.
- tomh- 17y agoTrue, hence "I wonder" when they do..is wondering something enough to downvote comments? And yes they do care about controlling the users, they just use other ways to enforce that (appstore, hardware lock-in)
- tomjen2 17y agoWell, I guess that means that I won't upgrade to win7. Way to make money fuckers.
- CodeMage 17y agoFor example, a major PC game manufacturer has apparently announced that their games will soon no longer run at all if you don't have an Internet connection to allow them to authenticate at each run. Which "major PC game manufacturer"? I don't doubt there is one -- BioWare attempted that once -- but I really dislike weasel phrasing. If you know which one, spell it out. If you don't know, research it first. Just don't write it like that.
- vetinari 17y agoIt is Ubisoft. See this http://www.shacknews.com/onearticle.x/62098 http://www.shacknews.com/onearticle.x/62098 (random article from google) for example.
- grOOvstEIn 17y agoUbisoft, for one. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=DRM+need+to+be+online+to+play http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=DRM+need+to+be+onli...
- CoryMathews 17y agoI do not see any problem at all with this. Its a completely valid thing for Microsoft to do. If you do not buy the software then you cannot use it. It's not a free OS. If you want a free OS go download some flavor of linux. Otherwise if you want windows you buy it. Why wouldn't they try to keep out people who have pirated their software? They could have made it auto forward all of ones information to the police, since technically they stole the software. I think annoying you with some pop-ups is a much more friendly way. The downvotes tell me we have some pirated versions out there ;)
- wendroid 17y agoThe concern is about a) false positives, b) what happens on non-internet connected machines inside secure facilities e.g. nuclear power stations, banks, police stations, hospitals &c. &c. So the only victims will ever be valid paying customers.
- chrischen 17y agoAs far as b) is concerned, it says if it can't connect to the validation server nothing happens. No penalty. As far as a) is concerned, call customer support. It says you might be able to get it for free if you are a victim of fraud, and if not you should be able to clear it up. You can easily bypass the activation limit by calling support, so something like a false positive should be easily correctable. I really don't see any valid excuse against this unless you pirate. And if you don't like the system for any legitimate reason, don't buy Windows.
- barrkel 17y agoAnd what if the company goes away? Or is acquired by another company that doesn't want to support it? Don't forget, this isn't just Windows. Other companies will point at MS and use it to justify their own actions.
- chrischen 17y agoIf the company goes away then the servers that invalidate your Windows will not do so anymore. This system would be a problem, but only if having a working OS depended on Microsoft keeping its servers up.
- zokier 17y agoI found this interesting piece "... the update runs quietly in the background protecting your system." Hopefully it really doesn't mean some kind of active protection eating precious resources.
- lurkinggrue 17y agoAh, "Protecting" as it would be a shame if anything were to break around here.
- jrockway 17y agoSuddenly, a pair of big, burly guys barge into your house and demand that you let them check your computer to make sure that it's "genuine" and not running pirated software. This wouldn't bother me at all. I would then say, "Come back with a warrant," and expect to never see them again. If they secure the warrant and come back, then they are legally-entitled to inspect the machine, which is fine. Too bad they don't know the password for my full-disk encryption, though. (My Win7 install is a VirtualBox image that runs inside my Linux install.) But anyway, I love strict enforcement of software piracy rules. If people become unable to pirate commercial software, they will use and improve Free Software -- ending the problem of proprietary software forever.
- bartl 17y agoYou may joke, but this happened to some people I know, a few years ago, by the BSA, here in Belgium. Not only do they check if you have anything installed now, but if there was anything, from the software companies they represent, ever installed, for which you cannot prove now, on paper, that you paid for it. They then offer you the choice to settle now, for a respectable sum of money, or be officially charged, and you can await your trial.
- jrockway 17y agoI would await my trial, where all the illegally-collected evidence becomes inadmissible, and the charges are dropped with prejudice. But of course, it would never get that far, because they wouldn't be allowed in my house, and they wouldn't be given the decryption key. (Any EULA they wave in front of you is invalid in the face of piracy; when you install pirated software, you are only violating copyright law, not the EULA. Let the police deal with it.)